My Kind of Club: The Inside Story of Neil Warnock's Cardiff City

[Eric the Half a Bee]

If I had the choice of Warnock or Malky again, I'd choose Malky every time, especially from his first season in charge where we played some rip-roaring, exciting football with a desire and graft missing from the previous seasons.

He led us to a cup final where we gave our best account of ourselves at a Wembley final since 1927. He won us the Championship title. He picked up the remnants of a side that had suffered promotion heartbreak season after season and had lost most of its best attacking players and got us into the playoffs.

Many cite Cornelius as a reason Malky failed, yet Warnock arguably spunked away more money than Mackay did.

[Pedro de la Rosa]

If I had the choice of Warnock or Malky again, I'd choose Malky every time, especially from his first season in charge where we played some rip-roaring, exciting football with a desire and graft missing from the previous seasons.

He led us to a cup final where we gave our best account of ourselves at a Wembley final since 1927. He won us the Championship title. He picked up the remnants of a side that had suffered promotion heartbreak season after season and had lost most of its best attacking players and got us into the playoffs.

Many cite Cornelius as a reason Malky failed, yet Warnock arguably spunked away more money than Mackay did.

Warnock has his enemies but Malky is racist, sexist, homophobic and anti-semitic. A lot of Warnock's signings (although not all) have come good too. As JRH says, he should have walked away after Man Utd.

[the other bob wilson]

Warnock has his enemies but Malky is racist, sexist, homophobic and anti-semitic. A lot of Warnock's signings (although not all) have come good too. As JRH says, he should have walked away after Man Utd.

The absolutely ideal time for Neil Warnock to retire from management would have been the day after we were promoted - I'd say his reputation was as high then as its ever been, but I'm beginning to wonder if he'll ever step away voluntarily from the job. If he got Middlesbrough promoted next season, he'd want to have "one last crack at the Premier League" and then if they went down a year later, he'd then be after his next promotion - just like he was here. Maybe the best thing for him these days is to be a trouble shooter on a short term basis for clubs in trouble because, almost without fail, he goes into a new club and makes a difference for the better, but he'll want more than that I'm sure.

I seriously believe that, provided his health holds up, he could still be managing in his eighties because desperate clubs are showing no signs yet of being put off by his age and while he continues to get relegation threatened clubs out of trouble , I don't see that situation changing - i reckon the jobs too ingrained in him to walk away from the game if someone says they want him.

[LeningradCowboy]

Warnock has his enemies but Malky is racist, sexist, homophobic and anti-semitic. A lot of Warnock's signings (although not all) have come good too. As JRH says, he should have walked away after Man Utd.

Hoilett
Bamba
Halford

Camp
Etheridge
Mendez-Laing
Paterson
Ward
Damour
Tomlin
Bogle
Madine

Cunningham
Murphy
Reid
Smithies
Bacuna

Day
Nelson
Vaulks
Flint
Whyte
Glatzel
Pack
Vassell

How many of these came good while Warnock was here?

[Pedro de la Rosa]

Hoilett - brilliant
Bamba - brilliant
Halford - free, good bloke and he filled in.

Camp - free, need a back up
Etheridge - outstanding
Mendez-Laing - brilliant
Paterson - brilliant
Ward - fine and done well in spells
Damour - good, and free
Tomlin - has his demons, look at him now
Bogle - gamble but scored in our promotion season
Madine - shit but we got up so who cares. terrible though

Cunningham - needed a left back, cheap for PL. bennett's form kept him out
Murphy - ok, he's lost his way
Reid - made money on him
Smithies - brilliant now and we needed a keeper in PL
Bacuna - if we spent 3m on him now you'd be really happy

Day - free, on peanuts and they expected Smithies to go
Nelson - great and free
Vaulks - limited but done really well post warnock
Flint - hmmm. not the best signing we've ever made. I hope we can sell but he's not been as bad as was made out but he's not been good either
Whyte - swap the w for an s. works hard and lower league gamble
Glatzel - i don't rate him but some do. he's not awful but he's not 5.5m
Pack - hard to say but i'd cash in. he probably was better under Warnock than he was for Harris
Vassell - crock, panic buy after reid and absolutely awful

How many of these came good while Warnock was here?

A lot have come good since. The freebies have been outstanding, his big money PL signings didn't come off.

[LeningradCowboy]

A lot have come good since. The freebies have been outstanding, his big money PL signings didn't come off.

I'm not sure you can give Warnock much credit for players who have come good under Harris. He'd still be playing Etheridge in goal, Flint alongside Morrison, and Pack instead of Vaulks in midfield.

It's incredible how his signings got worse the longer he was here and the more money he was given to spend.

[Bluebird23]

I'm not sure you can give Warnock much credit for players who have come good under Harris. He'd still be playing Etheridge in goal, Flint alongside Morrison, and Pack instead of Vaulks in midfield.

It's incredible how his signings got worse the longer he was here and the more money he was given to spend.

Like Harris did in the first keg against Fulham, which cost us big time!