| + Visit Cardiff FC for Latest News, Transfer Gossip, Fixtures and Match Results |
How about we say that Keene was obviously more than just a thug?
He's not Vinnie Jones.
He was certainly a 'thug' at that given moment, and there's no excuse. If he had carried that behaviour throughout his career then i would call him a thug, although a thug who could play. What he did was disgraceful, although i find it hard to brandish him a thug per se.Originally Posted by Hilts
And yes, he undoubtedly set out to do him, i'm sure he's said as much.
Yeah brilliant player.
It's difficult, i reckon that it comes down to personality. He hated Haland because he mocked him when he was injured, Keane saw it as questioning his integrity as a professional, probably a bigger insult to keane than stamping on his knee during a game. Vinnie, Fash and co kicked people and finished some off because they couldn't play and were looking for notoriety, which came in spades. What Keane did was disgraceful, although in his mind i reckon that he can justify it, that's not to say that i'm defending him.
Alex Ferguson and Brian Clough backed themselves I think
Ferguson and Clough didn't do an ounce of coaching, and they both allowed their players a night out or two. I don't think that players would respond well to that kind of management in today's environment. Not sure that's a good or bad thing thoughAlex Ferguson and Brian Clough backed themselves I think
Oh I thought you were talking about the idea of him thinking he's right about stuffFerguson and Clough didn't do an ounce of coaching, and they both allowed their players a night out or two. I don't think that players would respond well to that kind of management in today's environment. Not sure that's a good or bad thing though
title of thread is about bellamy! que you lot babbing about keane ferguson clough etc etc
Bellamy would do a great job, his heart is in football and he knows a pile o shite when he sees one.
He would try and get the best from his players.
I wouldn't mind taking a gamble on him.
Reading that article you know he is going to care at least as much as you do , his football knowledge is second to none .
Guaranteed success , no , of course not . But it has lots of positives in my mind.
They must have had the basics right before they let their players out?Ferguson and Clough didn't do an ounce of coaching, and they both allowed their players a night out or two. I don't think that players would respond well to that kind of management in today's environment. Not sure that's a good or bad thing though
If its just a matter of letting players go for a pint . If its just a matter of letting players out now and then I might apply for the job with Tomlin as my assistant....
That doesn't really set him apart from many people in football. The question is, if he sees "a pile o shite", what is he going to do about it? Has Bellamy even shown any interest in the job?
In the opening post I was arguing for Bellamy to become involved in the club again and drive standards and establish a culture of professionalism and excellence. I'm not convinced he is right or ready for the manager job, although it might be a genius appointment if it was made. It would be a gamble.
He has made mistakes in the past, but my sense is that he has learned and matured and is constantly trying to improve his skills and his ability to manage and lead others. He seems pretty self aware when he has been interviewed in recent years, and recognises that managing and coaching is different when you are not surrounded by elite players and elite facilities. He is no mug.
Bellamy was appointed Cardiff Player Development Manager in summer 2016 after a period of volunteer coaching at the club. He was in charge of the u18s. He applied for the Wales manager job. He applied for the Oxford manager job before withdrawing (and I think he subsequently regretted that). He has been Anderlecht u21 manager since summer 2019. I imagine he would be very interested in the Cardiff City managers job if it ever became available.
It was available just over a year ago. However, I always got the impression that Harris stepped down at Millwall because Warnock had pegged him his job when he did the same. Does anyone know?
Having said that, if Harris was sacked and Bellamy replaced him I wouldn't be too upset. At least it would be interesting. And we'd find out what he's capable of.
We will not get a manager who has proven his ability at this level or with his best management years in front of him.
So we have to compromise and make choices.I have long advocated Bellamy for the job. I hear that he gave a great interview for the Wales job prior to them giving it to Giggs. And there must be a reason Vincent Kompany chose Bellars to run his Academy. Nothing is without risk but Bellars is a risk worth taking.
Why not? We're a relatively big fish. We have a billionaire owner. We've spent two seasons in the EPL. We're clearly a club with long-term EPL ambitions even though we don't always show it.
I’m with you. I’d be happy for him to be given a shot at it. I’m certainly not going to pre-judge on some personal view of what I think or anyone else thinks of him as a human being
Bellamy would demand so much that he would just kill any team spirit after a while when he throws a wobbly after someone has a bad game
He would treat all his players in the same way. With a big stick, no carrot.
Some will respond, most wouldn’t.
If Harris did get sacked I’d let him have a try, but 90% sure he’d fail massively
People (on this board at least) continually talk about Craig Bellamy as a winner who demands the highest possible standards from those around him. So what did he actually win as a player?
Would that be a pre curser to a good manager?
Like Jose perhaps?
Not necessarily. I'm just interested to know where the idea that Bellamy is a serial winner comes from.
I think its more he appears to have a winning attitude . A determination to get the best out of the people .
Surely he did win things in his career? I haven't checked or followed his career that closely .
The League Cup against us
The Championship with City. A Scottish Cup with Celtic. I think he came on as a late sub when Liverpool won the Champions League. Apart from that, not sure if he won anything else?The League Cup against us
Don't think he came on, and they lost the final.
But anyway, isn't it about his personality rather than his trophy cabinet?
The charity shield .
Is it relevant ? Alex Ferguson hardly had a trophy laden career .
Posting Permissions
Reply With Quote