Is this guys sentence justified, or should it have been longer?

[Hilts]

Of course its too short.

Hes already hated out there though and this sentence is going to add to that.

Wouldn't like to be him walking the streets.

[BLUETIT]

You could argue, that he caused the deaths, by speeding !

If he wasn't speeding, there would have been no reason to stop him.

[sneggyblubird]

You could argue, that he caused the deaths, by speeding !

If he wasn't speeding, there would have been no reason to stop him.

I agree you could argue that he had a partial responsibility but the trouble is where do you stop.Maybe he should have stayed in bed.

[lardy]

I agree you could argue that he had a partial responsibility but the trouble is where do you stop.Maybe he should have stayed in bed.

I don't see how you can argue even partial repsonsibility for the deaths. If Mr Smith hits a pedestrian while driving to see his mum, is the mum partly responsible?

After all, Mr Smith wouldn't be on that road at the time if not for her, just as the police wouldn't have been there but for Pusey.

You can't dig that deep, just blame him for what he actually chose to do.

[lardy]

You could argue, that he caused the deaths, by speeding !

If he wasn't speeding, there would have been no reason to stop him.

He didn't cause the deaths, there was a lorry driver off his face who caused the deaths. He shouldn't be getting away with the public anger just because this guy was a total asshole.