Reply With QuoteThat makes no sense whatsoever. Why loan him to a championship side when we were already a championship side. Absurd decision by an absurd manager.Originally Posted by A Quiet Monkfish
| + Visit Cardiff FC for Latest News, Transfer Gossip, Fixtures and Match Results |
I hope it's just a question of fitness otherwise I can't see why Morison doesn't pick Bowen before the likes of Vaulks. I hope they haven't fallen out.
That makes no sense whatsoever. Why loan him to a championship side when we were already a championship side. Absurd decision by an absurd manager.
As Dembe says above its a thread about Wintle but to put it to bed as youre the second person on this thread today to mention Bowen I dont think we will be seeing him feature under Morison unless we have an absolute shedload of injuries.
I hope for the lads own career he gets a move in the summer and isnt made to rot in the under 23s for the final year of his contract. Should have been allowed to leave in January if the manager had no intention of using him.
Whilst Steve Morison is manager his Cardiff first team career would appear over before its began which is a shame, but such is life, some managers fancy you, some dont.
Oh the irony.
Vaulks played fine yesterday - what did he do wrong?
In my opinion he was ok, not fine. It's not what he did wrong it's that he hasn't the ability to be effective.
I'd rather a different option than Vaulks .
Wintle is very good , thought he had his best game Tuesday, love the way he gets about his business with no fuss , swift passing, he can go unnoticed as he does the simple things very well and quietly, bit like the mighty McPhail.
Hes good at what he does but hes no Mcphail. Mcphail could dictate the tempo of the game and had more strings to his bow than Wintle.
There's another player who was absolutely slaughtered by a section of our fanbase because he wasn't throwing himself into tackles and running around like a blue arsed fly
Correct.
To be fair to Wintle he hasnt the quality of players around him Mcphail had.
I dont think they are that similar anyway.
Wintle is quicker and a far more physical player.
Class again on Saturday, it's his simple passing that makes me think he's like McPhail, I do agree McPhail had other elements and differences to his game , early days though ?
Doing exactly what I saw him do wjen he was on loan at Blackpool.
Glad he is finally doing it for us.
To me they are 2 wildly different players
To me they are 2 wildly different players
McPhail was great felt I was always defending him but if anything I would want Wintle alongside McPhail. For me McPhail was at his best when we had Scimeca alongside him.
Defensively he's been a huge help. We looked all at sea before we stuck him in front of the back 4.
He did the swivel around in the spot thing host like McPhail yesterday and in fact he’s reminding me of him.
Only difference is Wintle is a bit quicker, but maybe hasn’t got the killer pass McPhail has.
However he’s excellent defensively and his ball retention is good too. Think although Vaulks has done pretty well since he’s come back in,Ralls is a far more capable player and reads the game so much better too. Balance looks good with Doyle, Ralls & Wintle.
Tough choices coming up for Morison
Hopefully he'll get a run of games with Ralls alongside him.
I was hoping to see a ralls, Wintle and Colwill at some point, possibly once we are definitely safe from relegation he'll start to explore more things
Same here, before we got Doyle.
Colwill seems our most natural replacement for Doyle
I think if we're going to persist with a 3 man midfield (we probably should) then Colwill definitely needs to be given some games there to see if he can do it. Realistically we'll be reliant on him to a certain extent next season
Posting Permissions