A Unique Achievement

[Eric the Half a Bee]

That's some conclusion

Can I have some of the acid you are dropping ?

Well either we are going to look at MMs time at Cardiff City from day one or we are going to look at the period when he went for that 5 across the back

So you're happy to look at McCarthy's record from day one. Fair enough. By your own admission, playing 5 at the back has been a mistake.

It didn't work , that's life

So if it doesn't work, how many more attempts has McCarthy got to get it to work, based on his initial successes after he took over? If the answer is zero, then you can't be happy with MM playing 5 centre backs. Otherwise, you are happy for him to keep giving 5 centre backs a go.