Quote Originally Posted by NYCBlue View Post
In my lifetime, Peter Whittingham. His coolness, his touch, his dead ball skill the way he would look up and do something outrageous. For the life of me, I still can figure out why he never made it to the top. Desire?
Probably because he was a passenger when he was at his most creative. When Mackay got him involved in things like defending and tackling, he lost his attacking flair. I'm not saying either scenario is better, but that's how it worked out.