+ Visit Cardiff FC for Latest News, Transfer Gossip, Fixtures and Match Results
Page 1 of 3 123 LastLast
Results 1 to 20 of 52

Thread: Rate the last ten Managers in order?

  1. #1

    Rate the last ten Managers in order?

    Dave Jones
    Malky McKay
    Neil Warnock
    Steve Morison
    Lenne Lawrence
    Neil Harris
    Mick McCarthy
    Ole Gunner
    Russell Slade
    Paul Trollope

    I haven't included Gabbidon as too brief, and taken a punt on Morison as it's a bit early to judge?

  2. #2

    Re: Rate the last ten Managers in order?

    For quality of player it's got to be Jones.Chopra,Jay,Whitts to name but a few.Success wise Malky and Neil.Lenny got us up.Morison wait and see.The rest not worth talking about.

  3. #3

    Re: Rate the last ten Managers in order?

    I predict a ten pager

  4. #4

    Re: Rate the last ten Managers in order?

    Quote Originally Posted by North Cardiff Blue View Post
    Dave Jones
    Malky McKay
    Neil Warnock
    Steve Morison
    Lenne Lawrence
    Neil Harris
    Mick McCarthy
    Ole Gunner
    Russell Slade
    Paul Trollope

    I haven't included Gabbidon as too brief, and taken a punt on Morison as it's a bit early to judge?
    I would agree entirely, other than I don't know where I would put Morison yet - think it's too early to place him, could be good or could still be a complete disaster.

  5. #5

    Re: Rate the last ten Managers in order?

    I agree that Dave Jones should be top. But when he was here this Board had nothing to say but bad things about him.

  6. #6

    Re: Rate the last ten Managers in order?

    Is that the same Dave Jones that didn't start Aaron Ramsey in the FA Cup Final?

  7. #7

    Re: Rate the last ten Managers in order?

    Quote Originally Posted by North Cardiff Blue View Post
    Dave Jones
    Malky McKay
    Neil Warnock
    Steve Morison
    Lenne Lawrence
    Neil Harris
    Mick McCarthy
    Ole Gunner
    Russell Slade
    Paul Trollope

    I haven't included Gabbidon as too brief, and taken a punt on Morison as it's a bit early to judge?
    I'd have Russell Slade higher than 9th and Morison below Lennie as its too early to judge.
    Trollope, OGS and MM were equally useless.

  8. #8

    Re: Rate the last ten Managers in order?

    It looks good, but I think Russel Slade deserves to be above Solksjaer and McCarthy seeing as he had a poisoned chalice of a job - no money to spend and he didnít play five centre backs - even though the football was dire.

  9. #9

    Re: Rate the last ten Managers in order?

    As said hard to judge Morison but then I suppose he’s had as much time as Trollope or longer not sure. I’d gladly put Malky at the bottom as can’t stand him but I’ll judge it on the job.


    Dave Jones
    Neil Warnock
    Malky McKay
    Lennie Lawrence
    Steve Morison
    Russell Slade
    Neil Harris
    Ole Gunner
    Mick McCarthy
    Paul Trollope

  10. #10

    Re: Rate the last ten Managers in order?

    Warnock

    Dragged us up from the pits

    Then got us promoted

    Dave Jones had loads of cash in terms of wages to play with

  11. #11

    Re: Rate the last ten Managers in order?

    Quote Originally Posted by North Cardiff Blue View Post
    Dave Jones
    Malky McKay
    Neil Warnock
    Steve Morison
    Lenne Lawrence
    Neil Harris
    Mick McCarthy
    Ole Gunner
    Russell Slade
    Paul Trollope

    I haven't included Gabbidon as too brief, and taken a punt on Morison as it's a bit early to judge?
    Malky
    Warnock

    These 2 miles ahead of everyone.

    Lennie below average but got us up.

    Morison as he kept us up big question marks still. Dont think he should be in the list to be fair.

    Harris
    Jones
    Slade any order.

    Trollope
    McCarthy
    OGS.

  12. #12

    Re: Rate the last ten Managers in order?

    Warnock
    Malky
    Jones
    Lawrence
    Harris
    Morison
    Harris
    Ole
    McCarthy
    Trollope

  13. #13

    Re: Rate the last ten Managers in order?

    Quote Originally Posted by North Cardiff Blue View Post
    Dave Jones
    Malky McKay
    Neil Warnock
    Steve Morison
    Lenne Lawrence
    Neil Harris
    Mick McCarthy
    Ole Gunner
    Russell Slade
    Paul Trollope

    I haven't included Gabbidon as too brief, and taken a punt on Morison as it's a bit early to judge?
    Malky
    Warnock
    Jones
    Lawrence
    Harris
    Slade
    Morrison
    Trollope
    Solskjaer
    McCarthy

  14. #14

    Re: Rate the last ten Managers in order?

    Quote Originally Posted by theclaw View Post
    Warnock
    Malky
    Jones
    Lawrence
    Harris
    Morison
    Harris
    Ole
    McCarthy
    Trollope
    Harris twice?

  15. #15

    Re: Rate the last ten Managers in order?

    Warnock
    Mackay
    Jones
    Lawrence
    Harris
    Slade
    Morison
    McCarthy
    Trollope
    Solksjaer

    I donít see how anyone can have Slade in the bottom 3, when the bottom 3 were so bad

  16. #16

    Re: Rate the last ten Managers in order?

    Quote Originally Posted by Hilts View Post
    Malky
    Warnock

    These 2 miles ahead of everyone.

    Lennie below average but got us up.

    Morison as he kept us up big question marks still. Dont think he should be in the list to be fair.

    Harris
    Jones
    Slade any order.

    Trollope
    McCarthy
    OGS.
    Youd rank Dave Jones as basically the same as Russel Slade?

  17. #17

    Re: Rate the last ten Managers in order?

    Criteria is too vague. Lenny Lawrence and Jones played the best football

  18. #18

    Re: Rate the last ten Managers in order?

    I terms of enjoyment;-

    Jones
    Lawrence (in 03/04)
    Mackay
    Warnock (for his first year)
    The rest much of a muchness, but I’ll go
    Harris
    Morison
    Ole
    Trollope
    Slade
    McCarthy

  19. #19

    Re: Rate the last ten Managers in order?

    Morison shouldn't be in this list as its too early, but what has he done to be above Lawrence, Harris and even Slade?

    The bottom 3 pretty much picks itself with Trollope, OGS and McCarthy. Jones, Mackay and Warnock the top 3

  20. #20

    Re: Rate the last ten Managers in order?

    Quote Originally Posted by dandywarhol View Post
    For quality of player it's got to be Jones.Chopra,Jay,Whitts to name but a few.Success wise Malky and Neil.Lenny got us up.Morison wait and see.The rest not worth talking about.
    Warnock or Harris? 🤣

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •