Poll thingy time....
| + Visit Cardiff FC for Latest News, Transfer Gossip, Fixtures and Match Results |
Yes
No
Poll thingy time....
Yes but initially a one year deal
Expectation levels need to be escaping relegation
He's impressed you that much?Originally Posted by SLUDGE FACTORY
and then bring back warnock...hell be almost 90 mind?
Yes.
Even though we're still teetering on the edge, he's got the most out of this batch of players, compared to the other managers.
His record is comparible with Hudson's.
No.
He'll tell the board investment is needed for the squad. They'll offer him a discount voucher for Subway and he'll leave. Even if he stays would he be someone who could rebuild?
I’d suggest anyone who can rebuild with this squad and no signings would get a better job than ours.
If he keeps us up he’ll have done the short term job, so if he actually wants to stay then he deserves a chance
Yes
What’s the alternative? Another coach with no management experience?
Give him a full season, a chance to reshape our squad and let’s see what he can do.
Totally agree
Before yesterday, I’d have definitely said yes, but after watching us play hoofball badly for ninety minutes in the closest thing I’ve seen this season to the bad, old days of McCarthy especially while also being a shambles tactically, I’m not so sure. On balance, I’d still say yes, but not with any great hope that things will be any better next season.
He completely messed up on Monday. HE didn't seem to know what he was doing and changed formations 4 times in the first half.
However, our three previous managers this season in Morison, Hudson and Whitehead couldn't get the players to perform consistently and therefore surely the problem is with the balance of the team and playing personnel.
Changing managers, even in the Summer, changes little.
The group needs to be added to with some leadership, character, fight and goals - all things we lack this season and things that can't be put right by constantly changing managers hoping that they wave a magic wand.
Let Lamouchi and Bamba get on with it and if we stay up let's see what they can do to address these issue - although their hands will be tied considerably.
Remember, it's not solely him where it comes to tactics.
He has a coaching staff that do all that background before games and report back to him. Therefore, it's likely they got it wrong.
Yes I would like to keep him
Too many commas man. (Not all in the right place) It’s like you discovered them a few years ago and now contrive text to maximise comma usage. Like it’ll get you from foundation to level 1. You never used to be like this. What happened
I used one too many I make it and that was made up for by the one I missed.
Because Collins, O'Dowda, and Robinson are out, the rest of the team were knackered from playing a few days before, he has a poor squad and came up against a team that had depth and could make five almost like-for-like changes.
Granted it didn't work, but f people think Bagan is the best we can do then we really are in trouble, can't everyone remember players skinning him and crossing with ease when we tried him before? It was probably worth the chance rather than doing what has failed on every previous time we've had to use him.
You know that Bagan has started 35 games for Cardiff City, right?
Hudson looked clueless and out of his depth and I think we'd be in the bottom 3 now if he stayed.
Lamouchi brought back some confidence and belief.
The way I look at it is who would they pick next?
It could be anybody. Their methods up to now have no rhyme or reason.
Stick with him whether he keeps us up or not. A definite no to cheap backroom staff masquerading as a manager without a penny to spend.
Yes, I like him, think he’s had a tough job to take over from.
Although biggest concern would be Bamba taking over if not which I think would be a disaster.
I think he will leave if we stay up or not.
This squad isnt his fault. But yesterday was such an organisational shambles I have doubts whether hes what we need.
However with such a poor squad a transfer embargo Im sure he will leave even if we survive.
I can't believe people have turned on him after so few games.
Modern football right there.
He might have got it wrong but you don't know what the injury situations were etc. He's also been left with an absolute crock of a playing squad and was brought in so late in the transfer window he couldn't even bring in loans with no fee.
As some have mentioned he recognised there was an issue and tried to change it. We could have got Warnock if Tan hadn't have burnt his bridges and accused every manager who hasn't nailed every transfer of conning him.
If people showed this much energy towards the owner and board we wouldn't be in this mess.
It wasn't Tan or the Board who were responsible for the left wing back fiasco yesterday.
Posting Permissions
Reply With Quote