Quote Originally Posted by Don Corleone View Post
None really, Smithies is a better keeper than either of the ones we have now but he was never staying

What about the best ever transfer window - list of players signed ( not including loans)

Allsop
Alnwick
Romeo
Simpson
Daley- Campbell
Collins
Tanner
O’Dowda
Sawyers
Ojo
Rinomhota
Adams
Robinson
Etete

Did I miss any other permanent signings?

Added to the squad - Robinson and O Dowda have been good signings. Etete was poor to begin with but has improved and may continue to do so therefore will include in this section

Average - Romeo and Allsop - I don’t rate Allsop but he’s not been awful, just we’ve been spoilt by much better keepers over the years. He’s okay as back up but would much prefer another number one.

Poor signings - Simpson, Sawyers, Rinomhota, Alnwick, Tanner and Daley -Campbell ( last two were only cheap gambles)

Terrible signing in a category of his own - Ojo

Jury out - Collins and Adams injured nearly all season, though Collins looked a good player in his first few games

Not the best result was it , half were awful signings - but still not many from the list of the ones we let go in 2022 would you keep over this lot.
Collins looked very good in his brief spell playing, and got man-of-the-match awards from most fans, lets's hope he comes back OK and not injury prone forever.