Which team would win

[WJ99mobile]

2014-2024 All Stars

GK 2022 Smithies
LB 2020 Bennett
CB 2021 Flint
CB 2018 Bamba
RB 2017 Peltier
CM 2024 Siopsis
CM 2016 Adeyemi
RM 2015 Noone
LM 2014 Bellamy
ST 2019 Paterson
ST 2023 Kaba

2003-2013 All Stars

GK 2010 Marshall
LB 2003 Barker
CB 2009 Johnson
CB 2006 Collins
RB 2011 Comminges
CM 2013 Gunnarsson
CM 2007 McPhail
RM 2004 Gray
LM 2006 Parry
ST 2012 Miller
ST 2008 Hasselbaink

[Maurice Swan]

2014-2024 All Stars hands down with their eyes closed....

[Eddie Johnson]

So pretty crazy omissions here, and Commingues and Flint? Where's Whitts, Earnie, Moore, Gabbidon, Ramsey to name a few?

[WJ99mobile]

So pretty crazy omissions here, and Commingues and Flint? Where's Whitts, Earnie, Moore, Gabbidon, Ramsey to name a few?

They weren’t bookable.

[NYCBlue]

2014-2024.

[2b2bdoo]

Tom Adeyemi was a funny one, thought he might progress to be a very good midfielder but it never seem to happen.

Only 32 now but his last games according to Wiki was 5 appearances for Ipswich between 2017/2019

[Jimmy the Jock]

Patterson

Unless there was another Patterson?

[ToTaL ITK]

Both would lose. Club's a joke ffs

[the other bob wilson]

Bellamy should be in the other team shouldn’t he?

I think the 03/13 team would murder the hoof it merchants.

[Tuerto]

Tom Adeyemi. If there was a player who made no impact whatsoever.

[Dembe]

So pretty crazy omissions here, and Commingues and Flint? Where's Whitts, Earnie, Moore, Gabbidon, Ramsey to name a few?

I don't know why the internet is like this. He wasn't calamine to have picked the best 11, he just wanted to know what one out of the 2 he randomly threw together would win?

I am completely undecided.

[jon1959]

Score draw.

[ToTaL ITK]

Score draw.

Rubbish! It would be 0-0 to Cardiff city

[MacAdder]

Obviously 2003-13.

The opposition have ten men, noone playing right midfield!

[dml1954]

Patterson

Unless there was another Patterson?

In our promotion season 2017/18 Paterson was one of our best players and got 9/10 goals from midfield.

[Eddie Johnson]

I don't know why the internet is like this. He wasn't calamine to have picked the best 11, he just wanted to know what one out of the 2 he randomly threw together would win?

I am completely undecided.

It was the All stars that got me.

[splott parker]

It was the All stars that got me.

Says Eddie Johnson

[HiVis]

I don't know why the internet is like this. He wasn't calamine to have picked the best 11, he just wanted to know what one out of the 2 he randomly threw together would win?

I am completely undecided.

definitely a sore subject, one that makes you itch.

[City123]

I don't know why the internet is like this. He wasn't calamine to have picked the best 11, he just wanted to know what one out of the 2 he randomly threw together would win?

I am completely undecided.

2014-24 for me, solid defence and Kaba & Paterson would get goals if supplied by Bellamy & Noone

[North Cardiff Blue]

Wheres the pitbull, Scimeca and Helguson ?