Looking at Burnley shef United and Luton did we actually do quite well in the Premier under warnock

[Father Dougal]

We finished with 34 points in 2019. Neil had a full season

Everyone is loving Luton this season but they only have 25 points with 5 games to go. Worse than us and very unlikely they will finish with more than 34.

We won 10 games in the Premier under warnock. Luton have won 6 this season but there seems to be a narrative about Luton being a tough place to go and they've made an impact on the league. Nobody says cardiff did?

Burnley have 20 points so would have to win all 5 games to overtake our return and shef u only have 16 points.

Just reflecting I suppose that warnock is always seen as such a premier league failure when even with us he did better than any of the teams promoted last season.

[A Quiet Monkfish]

We finished with 34 points in 2019. Neil had a full season

Everyone is loving Luton this season but they only have 25 points with 5 games to go. Worse than us and very unlikely they will finish with more than 34.

We won 10 games in the Premier under warnock. Luton have won 6 this season but there seems to be a narrative about Luton being a tough place to go and they've made an impact on the league. Nobody says cardiff did?

Burnley have 20 points so would have to win all 5 games to overtake our return and shef u only have 16 points.

Just reflecting I suppose that warnock is always seen as such a premier league failure when even with us he did better than any of the teams promoted last season.

Which really lays to rest the argument frequently postulated on here and the other place that Warnock should have been replaced with a 'PL manager' once promotion was achieved. He did a pretty decent job and almost kept us up..

[Father Dougal]

Which really lays to rest the argument frequently postulated on here and the other place that Warnock should have been replaced with a 'PL manager' once promotion was achieved. He did a pretty decent job and almost kept us up..

Yep. We finished 2 points below Brighton. One extra win and we'd have stayed up.

That Chelsea game........

Obviously the whole sala thing also.

Even in 13/14 we ended with 30 points. That's more than any of the bottom 3 this season Will probably get.

But main reflection is I'm not sure if people realise we did better than is often remembered.

[Eric the Half a Bee]

Yep. We finished 2 points below Brighton. One extra win and we'd have stayed up.

That Chelsea game........

Obviously the whole sala thing also.

Even in 13/14 we ended with 30 points. That's more than any of the bottom 3 this season Will probably get.

But main reflection is I'm not sure if people realise we did better than is often remembered.

We were relegated with a game to go. After we won at Brighton we had 4 games left and we were in 18th. We were 2 points adrift and Brighton (and Southampton a further 3 points above them) had a game in hand.

Some moan about the Chelsea result, but that didn't cost us. In the PL decisions go against you, particularly in favour of the big sides, even with VAR. Nobody mentions the crap performances at Fulham and at home to Palace when it was really needed, and that the Man Utd away game was a dead rubber. We forget that it took our 9th game to register a win. The offside winner against Brighton at home.

There seems to be some that say the Chelsea result cost us our PL place. It's nonsense. We just weren't good enough.

[Don Corleone]

We were relegated with a game to go. After we won at Brighton we had 4 games left and we were in 18th. We were 2 points adrift and Brighton (and Southampton a further 3 points above them) had a game in hand.

Some moan about the Chelsea result, but that didn't cost us. In the PL decisions go against you, particularly in favour of the big sides, even with VAR. Nobody mentions the crap performances at Fulham and at home to Palace when it was really needed, and that the Man Utd away game was a dead rubber. We forget that it took our 9th game to register a win. The offside winner against Brighton at home.

There seems to be some that say the Chelsea result cost us our PL place. It's nonsense. We just weren't good enough.

The crucial away game to Fulham was a very poor performance with what was at stake that day. And the Chelsea result was daylight robbery by the officials - but nobody knows how much the effect of what happened with Sala had on everyone at the club.

Both our seasons in the Premier league were not enjoyable - playing in red for the first season and the Sala tragedy for the 2nd one.

I still lament the Blackpool play off defeat - a Premier league season with that side, whilst possibly not being ultimately succesful, would no doubt have been a joyous ride, we had momentum , good entertaining footballers and a united fan base ( no red monstrosity dividing our support at that time!)

[North Cardiff Blue]

The crucial away game to Fulham was a very poor performance with what was at stake that day. And the Chelsea result was daylight robbery by the officials - but nobody knows how much the effect of what happened with Sala had on everyone at the club.

Both our seasons in the Premier league were not enjoyable - playing in red for the first season and the Sala tragedy for the 2nd one.

I still lament the Blackpool play off defeat - a Premier league season with that side, whilst possibly not being ultimately succesful, would no doubt have been a joyous ride, we had momentum , good entertaining footballers and a united fan base ( no red monstrosity dividing our support at that time!)

Good post that was our time, we are an unlucky club and injury to Bothrord at just the wrong time cost us.

[Citizen's Nephew]

The crucial away game to Fulham was a very poor performance with what was at stake that day. And the Chelsea result was daylight robbery by the officials - but nobody knows how much the effect of what happened with Sala had on everyone at the club.

Both our seasons in the Premier league were not enjoyable - playing in red for the first season and the Sala tragedy for the 2nd one.

I still lament the Blackpool play off defeat - a Premier league season with that side, whilst possibly not being ultimately succesful, would no doubt have been a joyous ride, we had momentum , good entertaining footballers and a united fan base ( no red monstrosity dividing our support at that time!)

^THIS^

[life on mars]

Which really lays to rest the argument frequently postulated on here and the other place that Warnock should have been replaced with a 'PL manager' once promotion was achieved. He did a pretty decent job and almost kept us up..

And Malky , but who is the tantalizing question

[SLUDGE FACTORY]

There are some right moaners on here

[Dembe]

There are some right moaners on here

Moaning about the moaners is worse, people are coming on here and expressing their own views, people are entitled to get frustrated and go through different ranges of emotions. You have your opinion, which it seems is allowed, so should people with different opinions be allowed. Get over yourself.

[J R Hartley]

Moaning about the moaners is worse, people are coming on here and expressing their own views, people are entitled to get frustrated and go through different ranges of emotions. You have your opinion, which it seems is allowed, so should people with different opinions be allowed. Get over yourself.

Amen.

[J R Hartley]

Moaning about the moaners is worse, people are coming on here and expressing their own views, people are entitled to get frustrated and go through different ranges of emotions. You have your opinion, which it seems is allowed, so should people with different opinions be allowed. Get over yourself.

Its ok to moan when he wants to moan about Colwill, or players he doesnt rate. Guys a clown.

[Dembe]

Its ok to moan when he wants to moan about Colwill, or players he doesnt rate. Guys a clown.

Im not so sure why theres a group on here that seem hell bent on not allowing others to have a different opinion, almost mocking people for daring to express a different view. If they read a negative opinion surely the easiest thing to do is scroll on instead of letting it bother them to the point they chase people around in their pro bulut jumpers...

[SLUDGE FACTORY]

Im not so sure why theres a group on here that seem hell bent on not allowing others to have a different opinion, almost mocking people for daring to express a different view. If they read a negative opinion surely the easiest thing to do is scroll on instead of letting it bother them to the point they chase people around in their pro bulut jumpers...

Having an opinion is fine

But you have shown time and time again you are here mostly for arguments

Which is why you have been banned several times

Maybe you will last a bit longer who knows

[SLUDGE FACTORY]

Moaning about the moaners is worse, people are coming on here and expressing their own views, people are entitled to get frustrated and go through different ranges of emotions. You have your opinion, which it seems is allowed, so should people with different opinions be allowed. Get over yourself.

You are another one who just slags off the players and management

It's not an opinion , it's just bollocks

[Dembe]

You are another one who just slags off the players and management

It's not an opinion , it's just bollocks

In your opinion.

[Moodybluebird]

We finished with 34 points in 2019. Neil had a full season

Everyone is loving Luton this season but they only have 25 points with 5 games to go. Worse than us and very unlikely they will finish with more than 34.

We won 10 games in the Premier under warnock. Luton have won 6 this season but there seems to be a narrative about Luton being a tough place to go and they've made an impact on the league. Nobody says cardiff did?

Burnley have 20 points so would have to win all 5 games to overtake our return and shef u only have 16 points.

Just reflecting I suppose that warnock is always seen as such a premier league failure when even with us he did better than any of the teams promoted last season.

This is something I've often thought about but never bothered starting a thread on. Every point you make is a valid one and it should also be noted we didn't win a game until our 9th attempt (Fulham home). In effect from then onwards we actually won a third of all our matches, which as you indicate stacks up very well when compared to Luton, Sheff Utd and Burnley.

As is the case today, we were not known for playing eye-catching football, which may account for why pundits were less than fulsome in their praise for us. I think we made a good fist of it all things considered and perhaps history will look back on Warnock's reign more kindly than it does at present.

[bobh]

We could have stayed up under Warnock if it wasn't for dodgy refs.
Remember in particular the offside goal for Chelsea (We'd have won that game) and the non-penalty vs Watford (2nd half would have been different)

[North Cardiff Blue]

We could have stayed up under Warnock if it wasn't for dodgy refs.
Remember in particular the offside goal for Chelsea (We'd have won that game) and the non-penalty vs Watford (2nd half would have been different)

And them spot on, we were robbed of so many points.

[Trigger]

No one loves and hates a club like a clubs own fans.

We were close under warnock, closer than some probably remember.

[North Cardiff Blue]

We finished with 34 points in 2019. Neil had a full season

Everyone is loving Luton this season but they only have 25 points with 5 games to go. Worse than us and very unlikely they will finish with more than 34.

We won 10 games in the Premier under warnock. Luton have won 6 this season but there seems to be a narrative about Luton being a tough place to go and they've made an impact on the league. Nobody says cardiff did?

Burnley have 20 points so would have to win all 5 games to overtake our return and shef u only have 16 points.

Just reflecting I suppose that warnock is always seen as such a premier league failure when even with us he did better than any of the teams promoted last season.

We would have stayed up if Sala hadn't taken that flight, not only for losing the 2nd best goals-scored Striker in France and the effect it had on Warnock, he wasn't the same for the rest of that season.

[Trigger]

We could have stayed up under Warnock if it wasn't for dodgy refs.
Remember in particular the offside goal for Chelsea (We'd have won that game) and the non-penalty vs Watford (2nd half would have been different)

The Chelsea decision was awful no doubt, a sliding doors moment.

But we would also have benefitted from other decisions, one I remember being where we beat Brighton late on.

[bobh]

The Chelsea decision was awful no doubt, a sliding doors moment.

But we would also have benefitted from other decisions, one I remember being where we beat Brighton late on.

Radio 5 Live did a piece on us. They normally hate us, but even they were saying there were something like 13/14 dodgy decisions against us, only in our favour.

[SLUDGE FACTORY]

Its ok to moan when he wants to moan about Colwill, or players he doesnt rate. Guys a clown.

Are you shagging each other ?

Stick to Merthyr you hermit

[J R Hartley]

Are you shagging each other ?

Stick to Merthyr you hermit

Ill stick to wherever I want Krusty