Reply With QuoteDeflection.Originally Posted by JamesWales
| + Visit Cardiff FC for Latest News, Transfer Gossip, Fixtures and Match Results |
Well funnily enough, it didn't read like a Valentine's card when you were talking about racism and xenophobia!
Deflection.
There's no deflection about it. It's a theory, I think a deeply flawed one that is creating greater divisions by emphasising our differences rather than what unites us. That's a perfect reasonable and sound conclusion. Others will have other conclusions.
Never quite understood the idea of protesting by smashing up your local area.
Not going to pretend I actually know what is going on so that's my only comment.
What surprised me was the amount of people who were blatantly committing extremely violent and antisocial acts on camera, with no attempt to cover faces. I hope the police are in their mob handed for the next few weeks pulling people and putting doors in.
Yeah I thought that. Saw a video on twitter a short while ago of a guy setting fire to a bus casually being filmed, no face covering or anything.
Yeah that was one that really got me. Along with the folks actually digging up the road in order to then throw it at the old bill.
Fair play to that Mothin Ali mind, certainly not my favourite politician but credit where it's due. Him and his mates were out trying to stop things, takes some real balls that and shows sone real community spirit. Unfortunately they seemed to be fighting a losing battle against the mob of loons
Of course there is
How on earth are you as a white bloke in Cardiff affected by critical race theory and its left wing supporters ?
Critical race theory ....
There's videos of white people damaging property , throwing missiles
How does this fit in ?
The reason that's off-the-scale offensive James is that it's supposition, accusatory, ill-informed, implies that I support divisive policy that contributes to racism in the community and..and..and... I didn't raise Critical Race Theory. You did. I countered your view that it contributes to division when it doesn't, it's a theory that has been hijacked by those criticising any criticism of racism.
You were apoplectic last week about Trump and standing up for decency and banging on about divisive language and calling things out. And to be absolutely clear, if I call a post out for being racist or verging on supporting far-right, racist ideology, that doesn't automatically assume I'm accusing the poster of being racist.
It's just that, I've said many times, it's not really a good look to start talking about race, referring to race, referencing ethnicity etc in a forum where, sadly, we are predominantly within one demographic and do not have the views of others who are, perhaps, in a better position to comment. Or, that we need that input to make the discussion balanced and equal.
Because I see growing racial divisions within the society I live in.
Don't be silly
No, I'm the same. Im not saying you implicitly support it, but I think it's an unintended but inevitable consequence of policies that (based on what you have said) I would assume you support.
I think dividing society up on racial lines is deeply regressive and is and will cause problems particularly in terms of integration.
I wasn't "apoplectic" but yes, I think some people's reaction to political violence and an attempted assassination in which a totally innocent man died was shocking. There are certain things that should cross the political divide. It's also a stunningly self defeating reaction because if people make light of then so too will their political detractors in reverse.
Your last point there; you've assumed that belief or otherwise in any theory should be rooted in our skin colour or background. I profoundly disagree, yet it illustrates my point well.
All the Tories' fault is the usual statement, even when it was Ely and Swansea.
Why not read the twitter feed and find out?
You weren't posting to find out what was happening, let's be honest. That would be obvious from a little snoop around twitter.
"GB news guy.
He's a twat."
If you're going to complain about people being offensive, maybe you should think about every single post you make.
I didn't complain about 'people' being offensive, I was referencing the reply by James to my argument. It was specific to his reply.
The GB guy is still a twat.
https://www.theguardian.com/politics...-and-harehills
‘This is what a councillor is supposed to do’: Mothin Ali on false accusations of rioting
The Green party councillor for Gipton and Harehills in Leeds was accused by the far right of taking part in rioting when he was trying to calm tensions
“People still are accusing me of being a rioter,” said Mothin Ali, the Green party councillor for Gipton and Harehills in Leeds.
It is true he was there on Thursday night when a police car was turned on its side, projectiles were thrown at riot police and a doubledecker bus was set alight in a night of unrest triggered when police turned up to help social services take some children into care.
But far from being a rioter, it was Ali, and others in the community, who stood in front of police in efforts to protect them, stopped people throwing bins and crates on the blaze and ultimately gathered water from nearby homes to put out the fire.
What made him put his safety at risk? “I don’t know,” he said. “It’s my area. I didn’t want people getting involved when they shouldn’t be getting involved. Throwing a rock and ending up with a 10-year jail sentence.
“And some of the police officers over the last few years I’ve got to know and I didn’t want them to get hurt. I thought, this is what a councillor is supposed to do.”
Early in the evening Ali was accused of rioting online by members of the far right, including Stephen Yaxley-Lennon, better known as Tommy Robinson, who claimed footage showed the “newly elected councillor for the area rioting tonight in Leeds. Multiple reports he’s even on the streets with them.”
Though many people saw the subsequent images and video of Ali protecting the community and giving rousing speeches to those gathered, some of the lies have stuck.
The hallmark of the entire right wing movement...opportunistic bullshit! Sadly, democracy is existentially vulnerable to this well orchestrated threat.
The comments I saw were complementary towards Mr Ali. Besides that, I don't think Yax is who he says he is.
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cyj41w72vn8o
'Four children whose removal into foster care prompted disorder in Leeds have now been returned to stay with their extended family.'
There was some controversy earlier as Mothin Ali was speaking into tiktok and saying the Police had language issues etc, which if viewed whilst watching the violence sounds bad, but the reality was that he was quite firmly keeping people away, telling them to think about any families living near the bins being set on fire and the like. Strikes me he did a great job, and was far more active in protecting his community than the vast majority of elected officials would have been.
Unfortunately the way these things work is that algorithms and the like will only show one side - this unfortunately happens across the spectrum and is - in my opinion - why I think political polarisation has got much worse since the era of social media, although that does slso coincide with the global financial crash in 20080from which we have never really recovered. As such, some will only see a negative side, others will only see a positive. The reality is always in the middle.
Anyway, whilst the incident doesn't shine a fantastic light on community relations and the like his behaviour deserves nothing but praise
Posting Permissions