+ Visit Cardiff FC for Latest News, Transfer Gossip, Fixtures and Match Results
Results 1 to 23 of 23

Thread: Could this team stay up in league one?

  1. #1

    Could this team stay up in league one?

    Alnwick

    Kpakio
    Lawlor
    Fish
    Bagan
    Giles

    J Colwill
    R Colwill
    Ashford
    Davies

    Salech

    Apart from up front and in goals as no options at all there it's mainly home grown (fish also)

    I wonder how much the wage bill would be?

    I'm not sure it would stay up though?

  2. #2

    Re: Could this team stay up in league one?

    Quote Originally Posted by Father Dougal View Post
    Alnwick

    Kpakio
    Lawlor
    Fish
    Bagan
    Giles

    J Colwill
    R Colwill
    Ashford
    Davies

    Salech

    Apart from up front and in goals as no options at all there it's mainly home grown (fish also)

    I wonder how much the wage bill would be?

    I'm not sure it would stay up though?
    Not a leader amongst them.

  3. #3

    Re: Could this team stay up in league one?

    Quote Originally Posted by Rock_Flock_of_Five View Post
    Not a leader amongst them.
    With a leader in cb and cm I wonder if they could stay up then?

  4. #4

    Re: Could this team stay up in league one?

    I hope CoD stays.. He's a leader. Did you notice that Alex Robinson was going to take the penalty yesterday.. However he ensured that Salech took it

  5. #5

    Re: Could this team stay up in league one?

    Quote Originally Posted by Armitage Shanks View Post
    I hope CoD stays.. He's a leader. Did you notice that Alex Robinson was going to take the penalty yesterday.. However he ensured that Salech took it
    I wondered if that was the normal tom foolery to protect the kicker etc like all sides seem to do now.

  6. #6

    Re: Could this team stay up in league one?

    Quote Originally Posted by Father Dougal View Post
    Alnwick

    Kpakio
    Lawlor
    Fish
    Bagan
    Giles

    J Colwill
    R Colwill
    Ashford
    Davies

    Salech

    Apart from up front and in goals as no options at all there it's mainly home grown (fish also)

    I wonder how much the wage bill would be?

    I'm not sure it would stay up though?
    Yes.

    That won't be anywhere near the team though.

  7. #7

    Re: Could this team stay up in league one?

    That team should be fine to stay up in League One. Rotherham had an absolutely revolting team in the Championship bar the goalkeeper who quickly got sold off, and still finished 16th this season (and yes, I know they beat us 5-2 in the final game that season, but we were absolutely on the beach at that point).

    There's an outside chance we could go on a colossal downward spiral, but I do think it's unlikely, even given the culture around the club. I'll predict we'll finish in the upper-half but either miss out on playoffs or lose in them.

  8. #8

    Re: Could this team stay up in league one?

    Yes. But that midfield would get bent over an awful lot.

  9. #9

    Re: Could this team stay up in league one?

    Quote Originally Posted by Der Kaiser View Post
    Yes. But that midfield would get bent over an awful lot.
    i beg your pardon..i know it's a lower league but they still have a modicum of decorum

  10. #10

    Re: Could this team stay up in league one?

    Itll stay up but that wont be the team.

    My blind optimism tells me providing we keep the majority of this team well kick arse in League one, go up automatically and then push on from there.

    But people dont want to hear that right now.

  11. #11

    Re: Could this team stay up in league one?

    Quote Originally Posted by WJ99mobile View Post
    It’ll stay up but that won’t be the team.

    My blind optimism tells me providing we keep the majority of this team we’ll kick arse in League one, go up automatically and then push on from there.

    But people don’t want to hear that right now.
    There will/should be a lot of movement in the team so we will have to see if the club has a plan or not.

  12. #12

    Re: Could this team stay up in league one?

    Quote Originally Posted by ToTaL ITK View Post
    There will/should be a lot of movement in the team so we will have to see if the club has a plan or not.
    Plan.🤣

  13. #13

    Re: Could this team stay up in league one?

    Alot depends on who their manager and coaches are.

  14. #14

    Re: Could this team stay up in league one?

    Yes but that wont be the team
    Well continue the off field stuff. The restructure will culminate in a change of manager for whatever is the cheapest option.
    Well skirt around near the bottom and hopefully avoid relegation

  15. #15

    Re: Could this team stay up in league one?

    Quote Originally Posted by WJ99mobile View Post
    It’ll stay up but that won’t be the team.

    My blind optimism tells me providing we keep the majority of this team we’ll kick arse in League one, go up automatically and then push on from there.

    But people don’t want to hear that right now.
    Completely agree, people seem to think just because we've been shit in this league we'll be shit in League 1. That isn't how it works and the proof is in the pudding for the majority of clubs relegated from the championship to league 1. Many come back quickly and a lot more are at absolute worst comfortably clear of relegation.

    If we struggle we will be a massive anomaly, but as you say people don't want to hear that, they are too in their feelings.

  16. #16

    Re: Could this team stay up in league one?

    we played a league one side last season, the team was

    Alnwick

    Kpakio McGuiness Bagan Giles

    Rinomhota King

    Conte Robertson Colwill

    Kanga

    with Fagan Walcott, Reindorf, Evans and Tanner coming off the bench.

    we won comfortably, with Colwill pulling the strings.

    admittedly that league one side would go on to be relegated by the end of the season, but it should at least be a bit encouraging about next season.

  17. #17

    Re: Could this team stay up in league one?

    Quote Originally Posted by Father Dougal View Post
    With a leader in cb and cm I wonder if they could stay up then?
    We need two or three decent centre-backs (they're all big in League One), and a two decent midfielders. In that five, there should be at least two born leaders. We've struggled all season without that type of player. The rest of the side should be okay.

  18. #18

    Re: Could this team stay up in league one?

    Quote Originally Posted by Father Dougal View Post
    Alnwick

    Kpakio
    Lawlor
    Fish
    Bagan
    Giles

    J Colwill
    R Colwill
    Ashford
    Davies

    Salech

    Apart from up front and in goals as no options at all there it's mainly home grown (fish also)

    I wonder how much the wage bill would be?

    I'm not sure it would stay up though?
    Probably.

    But I don’t understand the thought process of going down that route. We have a lot of players on the books who aren’t going to just go away.

    Maybe I’ll get this all wrong but apart from those that were with us on loan and those out of contract, I can’t see many major changes from the current squad. Maybe a 2 or 3 in out & in.

  19. #19

    Re: Could this team stay up in league one?

    Here's what I've worked out:

    Alnwick
    Bagan-Fish-Lawlor-Kpakio
    King
    Robertson-Colwill
    O'Dowda-Salech-Ashford

    Subs: Turner, Rinomhota, Giles, Conte, J Colwill, Tanner, Davies (Reindorf could be reserve/rotation)

    What we'll need:
    Another keeper, particularly if Alnwick is still injured.
    A couple of veteran defenders, we have good youth in the defence, but probably needs some leadership.
    A couple of veteran midfielders for the CDM and CM role, maybe another CAM too.
    Another option or two on the wing. I've liked Poku from Peterbrough, we were linked with him last season, and it doesn't seem like he's slowed down in any way.

    With Karl Robinson managing, we're serious auto-promotion contenders, so long as the morale at the club doesn't dip. We have good youth prospects ready to step into their own, just think we need a bit more leadership and experience now. Hopefully we'll sell enough to cover the loss of finances and get what we need in.

  20. #20

    Re: Could this team stay up in league one?

    With a solid plan over the summer, this team will bounce straight back. Unfortunately solid plans and tan and co don't seem to exist. Let's pray they have finally learnt some lessons!

  21. #21

    Re: Could this team stay up in league one?

    Quote Originally Posted by Coyote View Post
    Here's what I've worked out:

    Alnwick
    Bagan-Fish-Lawlor-Kpakio
    King
    Robertson-Colwill
    O'Dowda-Salech-Ashford

    Subs: Turner, Rinomhota, Giles, Conte, J Colwill, Tanner, Davies (Reindorf could be reserve/rotation)

    What we'll need:
    Another keeper, particularly if Alnwick is still injured.
    A couple of veteran defenders, we have good youth in the defence, but probably needs some leadership.
    A couple of veteran midfielders for the CDM and CM role, maybe another CAM too.
    Another option or two on the wing. I've liked Poku from Peterbrough, we were linked with him last season, and it doesn't seem like he's slowed down in any way.

    With Karl Robinson managing, we're serious auto-promotion contenders, so long as the morale at the club doesn't dip. We have good youth prospects ready to step into their own, just think we need a bit more leadership and experience now. Hopefully we'll sell enough to cover the loss of finances and get what we need in.
    So you’re getting rid of Horvath, Ng, Daland, Chambers, Turnbull, Wintle, Etete, Simic, Tsunoda, Willock & Robinson! A full starting 11!

    The manager is the most crucial signing.

  22. #22

    Re: Could this team stay up in league one?

    Quote Originally Posted by Des Parrot View Post
    So you’re getting rid of Horvath, Ng, Daland, Chambers, Turnbull, Wintle, Etete, Simic, Tsunoda, Willock & Robinson! A full starting 11!

    The manager is the most crucial signing.
    I forgot about Simic, he can stay. I have no idea what to do about Tsunoda, because he basically feels like he was brought in to skirt around some Belgian league rules for Kortrijk, I don't know enough about what the plans are for him, so I could take or leave him.

    And yes, we have to get rid of a fair few players to keep the crucial players and cover the financial shortfall. I'd like to keep people like Turnbull, Chambers, Horvath and even Robinson, but it's just not practical.

  23. #23

    Re: Could this team stay up in league one?

    Quote Originally Posted by Coyote View Post
    I forgot about Simic, he can stay. I have no idea what to do about Tsunoda, because he basically feels like he was brought in to skirt around some Belgian league rules for Kortrijk, I don't know enough about what the plans are for him, so I could take or leave him.

    And yes, we have to get rid of a fair few players to keep the crucial players and cover the financial shortfall. I'd like to keep people like Turnbull, Chambers, Horvath and even Robinson, but it's just not practical.
    Not practical for you maybe, but Berjaya has approximately $5.5 Billion of assets. We’ll soon find out Vincent’s resolve. All 11 of those players are under contact, some to the end of 25/26, most to 26/27 and some until the end of 27/28. It’s not just the transfer fee to buy out, it’s the contract as well.

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •