I thought these ratings from WalesOnline looked very harsh. Nothing above a 6!

http://www.walesonline.co.uk/sport/f...s-17713745.amp

Smithies - 6 (the shot he bobbled at the end bounced up very awkwardly at the last second thanks to a shit pitch)

Richards - 5
Morrison - 7 (so happy for him after Swansea away)
Nelson - 5 (worst performance yet)
Bennett - 6

Vaulks - 7
Pack - 6

Adomah - 8
Tomlin - 7
Murphy - 6

Paterson - 6