Bellamy for me. That was a genuinely astonishing signing. He had been one of Man City'd best performers the year before when they just missed out on the champions league. Pretty sure he scored a dozen or so premier league goals.

He also went to Liverpool the season after, and I can't see that happening with Rambo.

That's not to diminish the signing at all. It's a fantastic signing but I think an objective look at it would suggest Bellamy was the bigger deal..albeit only on loan.