I think the problem here is two fold
We are talking about events as if they are facts that are alleged to have happened 2000 plus years ago
Huge alarm bells
Then we have someone who is a non Christian.....yeah right ... coming to the conclusion that Jesus rising from the dead is more likely than some of Jesus's mates taking his body away
If I was listening to someone telling me this I would think he's either having a laugh and a joke ,hes a conman and must think I am stupid or he needs to be talking to a psychiatrist
It's a load of nonsense