One reason why religion is a load of bollox.

[JamesWales]

Re: One reason why religion is a load of bollox.

Hitler may have opposed the church but the roman Catholic popes definitely supported him

I think they saw the writing on the wall as much as anything and were pretty gutless in opposition. Which is definitely a criticism of the catholic church, but at that time in europe, atheists were murdering people due to their faith, so its definitely not a story that advocates militant atheism either.

It's all about balance and tolerance really. There's good and bad in everyone, every country, every religion etc etc

[SLUDGE FACTORY]

Re: One reason why religion is a load of bollox.

You don't have to be a person of faith to do good things

That's what annoys me about religious people

They think it's god influencing them to do good things

It's bollocks

You don't have to go to church or be religious to do good things or be kind

You can be a member of the local chess club and still be kind and help the homeless

People are human beings and in general don't do something for nothing

People who go to church and pray do so because they want to get to this place called heaven

They help the poor because they think it will make God think they are good people and he will look after them

Some bloke who is on the dole and gives a quid to a homeless person is every bit as good a person as the couple all dressed up singing in church on a Sunday

My view is there probably isn't a god but if there is I will have done enough to have be let into his paradise

[SLUDGE FACTORY]

Re: One reason why religion is a load of bollox.

I think they saw the writing on the wall as much as anything and were pretty gutless in opposition. Which is definitely a criticism of the catholic church, but at that time in europe, atheists were murdering people due to their faith, so its definitely not a story that advocates militant atheism either.

It's all about balance and tolerance really. There's good and bad in everyone, every country, every religion etc etc

I agree with that

Apart from jacks

All vermin

[AfricanBluebird]

Re: One reason why religion is a load of bollox.

All institutions, religious or not (royal family, media, education, sports clubs, churches and workplaces etc) are often breeding grounds for sexual abuse and sexual misconduct.

The particular issue with religious institutions where this happens is particularly gruelling as they 'pretend' and set themselves up as the 'good' and morally superior than the rest of us.

MANY religious institutions are however leading the way in safeguarding children in their emergency response programs. But I can't tell you how many people, who would define themselves as 'religious', I have investigated for child abuse here in Uganda and other parts of the world using their religion, mission or church as a cover for their behaviour.

However they would probably do it anyway, even without their religious cover, and just find another way to do it.

The thing we need to be better at is tearing organisations apart when they have been found to actively cover stuff up.

[SLUDGE FACTORY]

Re: One reason why religion is a load of bollox.

All institutions, religious or not (royal family, media, education, sports clubs, churches and workplaces etc) are often breeding grounds for sexual abuse and sexual misconduct.

The particular issue with religious institutions where this happens is particularly gruelling as they 'pretend' and set themselves up as the 'good' and morally superior than the rest of us.

MANY religious institutions are however leading the way in safeguarding children in their emergency response programs. But I can't tell you how many people, who would define themselves as 'religious', I have investigated for child abuse here in Uganda and other parts of the world using their religion, mission or church as a cover for their behaviour.

However they would probably do it anyway, even without their religious cover, and just find another way to do it.

The thing we need to be better at is tearing organisations apart when they have been found to actively cover stuff up.

The Catholic Church has covered up and provided cover for child abuse for hundreds of years

These safeguarding children departments are laughable , run by the pope

It's like giving a robber your credit card

Religion is archaic and based on fairy tales and fantasy

Science is progress and this is what should be fed to our children , not fake stories about making blind men see and disabled people suddenly being able to walk because the son of God blessed them 🙏

[Baloo]

Re: One reason why religion is a load of bollox.

You don't have to be a person of faith to do good things

That's what annoys me about religious people

They think it's god influencing them to do good things

It's bollocks

You don't have to go to church or be religious to do good things or be kind

You can be a member of the local chess club and still be kind and help the homeless

People are human beings and in general don't do something for nothing

People who go to church and pray do so because they want to get to this place called heaven

They help the poor because they think it will make God think they are good people and he will look after them

Some bloke who is on the dole and gives a quid to a homeless person is every bit as good a person as the couple all dressed up singing in church on a Sunday

My view is there probably isn't a god but if there is I will have done enough to have be let into his paradise

I reckon empathy and collaboration has probably offered evolutionary advantage so ultimately, whether you're religious or not, it's ultimately rooted in self-interest. Nothing wrong with that of course, we're wired this way though natural selection and it can still provide many people and animals with more meaningful and productive lives. That's not to say of course everybody will behave that way whatever their beliefs.

[AfricanBluebird]

Re: One reason why religion is a load of bollox.

Aye

The Catholic Church has covered up and provided cover for child abuse for hundreds of years

These safeguarding children departments are laughable , run by the pope

It's like giving a robber your credit card

Religion is archaic and based on fairy tales and fantasy

Science is progress and this is what should be fed to our children , not fake stories about making blind men see and disabled people suddenly being able to walk because the son of God blessed them 🙏

I don't disagree Sludge. The catholic church is implicit in 100's of years of cover up.

What I do see is some religious based organisations (not churches) doing some good work in this area. As an example, LWF in Uganda work in refugee communities (about 400000 people) and are one of the best organisations that help protect child, better in fact than some non-religious ones.

[Rjk]

Re: One reason why religion is a load of bollox.

Religion pervades every culture on the Earth. It seems as though were born to do it.

I find Dawkins' ideas on the reasons for religion fairly convincing.
I.e. it is an evolutionary side-effect of a beneficial trait - believing what the elders have told you when you were growing up.

this berry is poisonous, this is the correct way to cook this plant, we don't eat this animal etc etc are easy to see how that is a beneficial trait

this is then twisted and used to control people and wield power by people over the centuries.

That isn't to say that people don't take positives from organised religions today as well.
It can be a way of meeting and making friends, can provide pastoral care to vulnerable people, gives people a mechanism for thoughtfulness and self reflection, helps people form a cohesive cultural identity. Reaching out to the vulnerable with charitable acts etc

I think that this is just people doing good and the religion os providing the framework for that, so the flip side is probably also true - the murdering, discrimination, child abuse, judging and other terrible things that people do in the name of religion aren't because of the religion, but the religion is just the mechanism that is being used by bad people to do them.

as such I don't think religions are inherently good or bad - they are just something we are programmed to do. and perhaps we should approach them with that in mind.

I think we see this trait manifest itself in other ways also - how many non religious people HAVE to eat turkey on christmas day - even if they don't particularly like it and don't eat it any other day of the year.
How many people support the monarchy - not because they think it is the best system for a head of state, but because they feel that that is the way that WE as a nation do things and to change it seems contrary to our traditions (the royal family absolutely play on this btw)

[Tuerto]

Re: One reason why religion is a load of bollox.

Hitler may have opposed the church but the roman Catholic popes definitely supported him

Sludge, if you ever get the chance, do some reading up on the resistance groups formed by priests, nuns and the congregation, who fought against Hitler, Franco and Mussolini. It's fascinating stuff and shows that having a puerile outlook on those with faith is a very big mistake to make.

[SLUDGE FACTORY]

Re: One reason why religion is a load of bollox.

I don't disagree Sludge. The catholic church is implicit in 100's of years of cover up.

What I do see is some religious based organisations (not churches) doing some good work in this area. As an example, LWF in Uganda work in refugee communities (about 400000 people) and are one of the best organisations that help protect child, better in fact than some non-religious ones.

I agree

[SLUDGE FACTORY]

Re: One reason why religion is a load of bollox.

Sludge, if you ever get the chance, do some reading up on the resistance groups formed by priests, nuns and the congregation, who fought against Hitler, Franco and Mussolini. It's fascinating stuff and shows that having a puerile outlook on those with faith is a very big mistake to make.

I am afraid that as the vast majority of roman catholics look to the Vatican and the pope for how they should behave ......which is very odd ......the actions of partisans , small in number against the fascists , is not really good enough to convince me that a lot of religious people are incredibly stupid and need to be treated like kids

[goats]

Re: One reason why religion is a load of bollox.

20 pager on way I reckon

[Tuerto]

Re: One reason why religion is a load of bollox.

I am afraid that as the vast majority of roman catholics look to the Vatican and the pope for how they should behave ......which is very odd ......the actions of partisans , small in number against the fascists , is not really good enough to convince me that a lot of religious people are incredibly stupid and need to be treated like kids

Not all Catholic people look to the pope, not all of them agree with everything that is said by him or written in the Bible, or said by the priest etc. It doesn't really work like that. There will always be hard liners, but I'd say that the vast majority aren't that interested in what the pope has to say, especially those in more developed cultures.
In my opinion, your view is very narrow and you're pandering to the reactionary by lumping everyone who has faith into the same category. Big mistake in my opinion. Would you say that all poor people are just lazy, people who suffer with mental health are weak etc? Of course you wouldn't, as that would be generalising, which almost certainly panders to the most extreme amongst us, and as a result, ends In people being persecuted because of a certain belief etc

[AfricanBluebird]

Re: One reason why religion is a load of bollox.

During WW2 the catholic church and priests bravely helped highlight and advocate against the Nazi's Kinder-Euthanasie policy - a policy that was essentially killing disabled children. However, the Catholic 'church' (as an institution) didn't extend that same love or bravery towards the Jews in Germany who were being shipped of to concentration camps - despite being told and informed by their some of their own Priests.

In fact the biggest issue the Catholic Church had with the Nazis was that the Nazis wanted to stop resources being sent to the Catholic church. Incidentally, the Catholic church helped many Nazis flee to south America and other places immediately after the war to escape prosecution.

However we have to separate the 'church' and people. There are many many Catholics and priests who opposed the Nazis and lost their lives for it. In particular the Jesuits. But the Catholic church as an 'institution' and huge numbers of followers went along with the Nazis.

[SLUDGE FACTORY]

Re: One reason why religion is a load of bollox.

Not all Catholic people look to the pope, not all of them agree with everything that is said by him or written in the Bible, or said by the priest etc. It doesn't really work like that. There will always be hard liners, but I'd say that the vast majority aren't that interested in what the pope has to say, especially those in more developed cultures.
In my opinion, your view is very narrow and you're pandering to the reactionary by lumping everyone who has faith into the same category. Big mistake in my opinion. Would you say that all poor people are just lazy, people who suffer with mental health are weak etc? Of course you wouldn't, as that would be generalising, which almost certainly panders to the most extreme amongst us, and as a result, ends In people being persecuted because of a certain belief etc

Yes it does , that's how these bodies survive . Money and people indoctrination others .

The vast majority of roman catholics look towards the Vatican and the pope for guidance as he is their spiritual leader on earth

They don't practice what they preach but the catholic church is against homosexuality , sex before marriage and abortion .

I am afraid either you are hiding a secret religious leaning or you are not facing reality

The comparison with mental ill health is of course nonsense

People are not taught to be mentally ill , or go every Sunday to a place that helps them to be mentally ill

Mental illness happens

To compare saying something like pull yourself together to a mentally ill person to the fact that roman catholics are brainwashed is ludicrous

Why would I say that mentally ill people are weak or the poor are lazy in the same way that religious people are brainwashed ?

Mentally ill people are ill , poor people are poor

Anybody who goes to church on a Sunday and has a priest read to them the latest directive from his holiness the pope is brainwashed .

We sing cardiff city are the greatest team in football the world has ever seen ......but we don't believe it , its clearly nonsense

I think defending the right for someone to believe in God is up to the individual , if you want to do that then carry on but I am saying religious people are indoctrinated , especially roman catholics and if someone is defending the right of someone to believe in a bloke sitting on a cloud then its 2021 and there are people still waiting for evidence he exists , never mind having people like you tell me I can't generalise about people who are clearly devoted to something that clearly doesn't seem to be there .