Bulut or Lamouchi

[2b2bdoo]

Re: Bulut or Lamouchi

Not bambas biggest fan then

Despite most cardiff fans I know thinking he's a good asset

Not really but it doesn’t matter what I think or what your mates think. If the new manager wants Bamba then fine get him signed up but I don’t want the club to push him on the new manager to just please some fans. Let the manager bring in his people whoever they may be.

I’m not sure how anyone knows how good a coach Bamba is from just watching him shout a bit on the sideline and doing some fist pumps when we win.

[fugsyphil]

Re: Bulut or Lamouchi

Lamouchi did the job of staying up and a couple of the away games were decent. However the home performances offered nothing to deserve getting retained so I wasn't shocked he was let go.
Can't give you any honest opinion about Bulut yet as I only vaguely know the name and very much doubt anyone on this site have watched his teams play often enough to make an informed choice.

[dml1954]

Re: Bulut or Lamouchi

Fans respect results, they don’t care who the coach is.

Confrontational? Surely you have seen it? He lost it the other week on the side line with Peltier, unprofessional. He lost it with Warnock as a player on the side line. He clearly can’t control his temper.

Ego? Expecting a call off the chairman when being released despite being told by the manager and the big clue not getting a new contract but still chose to slam the club in the media to keep him relevant.

If he’s a good coach despite his minimal coaching experience and the new manager wants him then perfect. Personal think the manager should choose his staff and not be because they used to play for us.

How is anyone ever going to know if someone is going to be a good coach if they keep wanting to get rid. You pick on two instances where he showed his passion for the club and lost his cool and totally forget to take account of all the good things he did. When he fell out with Warnock on the sideline, he had just seen a team mate taken out with a knee high tackle. Plus what I know is that Bamba was a bloody good player for us and knows the club inside out, something that a manager coming in from abroad will find invaluable. You need to show him more respect.

[2b2bdoo]

Re: Bulut or Lamouchi

How is anyone ever going to know if someone is going to be a good coach if they keep wanting to get rid. You pick on two instances where he showed his passion for the club and lost his cool and totally forget to take account of all the good things he did. When he fell out with Warnock on the sideline, he had just seen a team mate taken out with a knee high tackle. Plus what I know is that Bamba was a bloody good player for us and knows the club inside out, something that a manager coming in from abroad will find invaluable. You need to show him more respect.

He was a brilliant player for us.

If the new manager wants him then fine, but it should be the managers choice imo.

[Rjk]

Re: Bulut or Lamouchi

better the devil you don't know

[North Cardiff Blue]

Re: Bulut or Lamouchi

Neither Nathan Jones, knows the league, knows the players, knows and loves the club!

The timing was perfect and we brought in some complete randomer from Turkey.

I don't trust Tan or Dalmon, they get it wrong eight times out of ten on Management appointments.

[Eric the Half a Bee]

Re: Bulut or Lamouchi

Well we know that no manager , coach or player will ever be good enough for you

But I think bamba under lamouchi did OK

In what respect? I know nothing about how Bamba did under Lamouchi.

[Eric the Half a Bee]

Re: Bulut or Lamouchi

Plus what I know is that Bamba was a bloody good player for us and knows the club inside out, something that a manager coming in from abroad will find invaluable.

Excellent. Bulut has got someone to give him a tour of the club and its facilities.

All of what you've written there makes absolutely no difference to Bamba's ability as a coach. None of us know if Bamba is any good.

[North Cardiff Blue]

Re: Bulut or Lamouchi

Excellent. Bulut has got someone to give him a tour of the club and its facilities.

All of what you've written there makes absolutely no difference to Bamba's ability as a coach. None of us know if Bamba is any good.

Great bloke but he doesn't come across as a knowledgeable coach like Bellamy when interviewed, or as a football pundit but who knows, I guess we will soon find out if he is jettisoned.

[Bobby Dandruff]

Re: Bulut or Lamouchi

So we have appointed Bulut, what would people prefer we kept Lamouchi or happy we have changed.

I didn’t mind Lamouchi if the other options were Bamba or Morison but I think it’s a positive step forward.

LFW

[Eric the Half a Bee]

Re: Bulut or Lamouchi

Great bloke but he doesn't come across as a knowledgeable coach like Bellamy when interviewed, or as a football pundit but who knows, I guess we will soon find out if he is jettisoned.

Bulut won't know about Bamba as a coach until he's worked with him.

For the likes of Sludge, I'm genuinely not having a downer on Bamba, I just wish I knew a bit about how he's doing.

[the other bob wilson]

Re: Bulut or Lamouchi

Maybe the conversation has gone off on a Sol Bamba tangent in this thread because the original question is such a tough one to answer gibven none of us really know anything about Bulut. I was not sad to see Lamouchi go, home performances became truly abysmal under him after we’d played pretty well in some of his early ones and, for all that he’s praised as being a “proper” manager by some in comparison with Morison and Hudson, his record was barely better than theirs.

I chose Bulut in the poll, but only because there was no don’t know option. I’ve said I don’t like much of what I’ve read about Bulut since his appointment, but I’m hoping that Steve Caulker is right when he claims he adjusts his approach according to the strength of the opposition, because that’s no bad thing in my book.

[Rjk]

Re: Bulut or Lamouchi

Maybe the conversation has gone off on a Sol Bamba tangent in this thread because the original question is such a tough one to answer gibven none of us really know anything about Bulut. I was not sad to see Lamouchi go, home performances became truly abysmal under him after we’d played pretty well in some of his early ones and, for all that he’s praised as being a “proper” manager by some in comparison with Morison and Hudson, his record was barely better than theirs.

I chose Bulut in the poll, but only because there was no don’t know option. I’ve said I don’t like much of what I’ve read about Bulut since his appointment, but I’m hoping that Steve Caulker is right when he claims he adjusts his approach according to the strength of the opposition, because that’s no bad thing in my book.

I've seen similar written in - of all places - someone trying to show how to set up football manager to accurately represent Bulut's tactics.
against weaker sides they were very aggressive in pressing and tried to keep the ball in the opposite half
against stronger sides they didn't press until very deep, kept a low block and played on the counter attack

[Eric the Half a Bee]

Re: Bulut or Lamouchi

Slightly odd poll in that you're asking to compare a manager we have no experience of. Shit polls are my domain. Who can forget the total lack of interest in my toilet duck fragrance poll of 2011?

[North Cardiff Blue]

Re: Bulut or Lamouchi

Bulut won't know about Bamba as a coach until he's worked with him.

For the likes of Sludge, I'm genuinely not having a downer on Bamba, I just wish I knew a bit about how he's doing.

No he will have to take advice from the club and interview him, some Managers always like to bin and bring in their own, let's see what type this one is.