Yesterday's "Penalty"

[Kerkyra Blue]

Clear penalty for me . We have had 1 penalty all season joint bottom of the penalty table . The most pens teams have in League 1 are Luton with 7 and Stockport with 6 .

[delmbox]

Re: Yesterday's "Penalty"

Absolute stonewall

[LA Bluebird]

Re: Yesterday's "Penalty"

Clearest penalty I've seen in a long time, then went down the other end and didn't give Burton a free kick outside the area for an equally obvious foul to even it up. Another very poor ref, probably even more notable in the step down in quality from Champ to League One is how awful the officiating has been.

[The Lone Gunman]

Re: Yesterday's "Penalty"

Not a penalty. The replay shows Ng slipped while trying to turn. Great picture of it on the BBC match report.

[The Lone Gunman]

Re: Yesterday's "Penalty"

https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/live/c8j3vlppx00t

[Steve the Tea]

Re: Yesterday's "Penalty"

The Burton player had both feet off the pitch as he jumped in and was not in control of challenge. That is a red card according to the Laws.

StT.
<><
:tea:

[The Lone Gunman]

Re: Yesterday's "Penalty"

The Burton player had both feet off the pitch as he jumped in and was not in control of challenge. That is a red card according to the Laws.

Nonsense.

[Steve the Tea]

Re: Yesterday's "Penalty"

Nonsense.

Each to his own.

StT.
<><
:tea:

[MacAdder]

Re: Yesterday's "Penalty"

Stone wall pelanty.
The defender was done up like a kipper and lunged
Referee another homer.

[Rock_Flock_of_Five]

Re: Yesterday's "Penalty"

https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/live/c8j3vlppx00t

They say the camera never lies. However, I'd prefer to analyse a slowed-down recording of the penalty claim, rather than a still photo.
Where the defender's boots were, a split second earlier, would have shed more light on the incident.

[Undercoverinwurzelland]

Re: Yesterday's "Penalty"

The defender certainly flies in in a dangerous manner and doesn't get the ball.

https://x.com/LeagueOne25/status/2017654631300481121

[IanD]

Re: Yesterday's "Penalty"

https://www.skysports.com/football/video/26947/13501652/burton-2-2-cardiff-league-one-highlights

Stonewall penalty. Have a look (for the best angle) at 30 to 32 secs.

[Kitman]

Re: Yesterday's "Penalty"

https://www.skysports.com/football/v...one-highlights
Stonewall penalty. Have a look (for the best angle) at 30 to 32 secs.

A penalty appeal that makes it onto the highlight reel hints that the Sky TV editors also think it was a stonewall pen

Either that or the he game was devoid of any other exciting incident

[IanD]

Re: Yesterday's "Penalty"

A penalty appeal that makes it onto the highlight reel hints that the Sky TV editors also think it was a stonewall pen

Either that or the he game was devoid of any other exciting incident

Yes, unusual Sky include a penalty appeal. They didn't include our very nearly third goal when no-one was there to tap in. There was a camera in the stand to our right that should have caught the simulated foul that led to the free kick/equaliser. Not sure if it was Sky though. Nothing in the highlights from that angle so, I assume, it was a Burton camera and they are keeping the evidence quiet. Should have been a yellow for simulation. Terrible refereeing...again.

[Lord Worcester]

Re: Yesterday's "Penalty"

Clearest penalty I've seen in a long time, then went down the other end and didn't give Burton a free kick outside the area for an equally obvious foul to even it up. Another very poor ref, probably even more notable in the step down in quality from Champ to League One is how awful the officiating has been.

My exact words to my lad at the time. His not awarding the free kick at the other end was his first opportunity to start to even up. You can almost see his thought bubble - I do think refs are quite transparent in their thought process and decision making at times. It was a foul on Perry and therefore should have been a penalty. No question.