If this is your first visit, be sure to
check out the FAQ by clicking the
link above. You may have to register
before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages,
select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.
Next match: Pre-season. Saturday, July 11th | FC Midtjylland (H) @ Cardiff City Stadium, 12:30pm -
All pre-season fixtures
As long as the BBC continue to have Garth Crooks on their version of the show, then Soccer Saturday will be more successful.
Some of the new pundits are a refreshing change from Phil Thompson et al, and hopefully a new presenter (should be that Julian fella) will keep the continuity.
As long as the BBC continue to have Garth Crooks on their version of the show, then Soccer Saturday will be more successful.
Some of the new pundits are a refreshing change from Phil Thompson et al, and hopefully a new presenter (should be that Julian fella) will keep the continuity.
the beeb one has always just seemed cheaply made by comparison
the beeb one has always just seemed cheaply made by comparison
I know that I'm in a massive minority, and I'm probably the one who is wrong on this, but I couldn't care less who is commentating or who is doing the punditry. I understand that soccer Saturday is different, and personalities play a significant part in the whole event, but as far as I'm concerned, a live match could have anyone communicating or doing the punditry, it's the game that I watch and I never listen to anything any of them say anyway.
I know that I'm in a massive minority, and I'm probably the one who is wrong on this, but I couldn't care less who is commentating or who is doing the punditry. I understand that soccer Saturday is different, and personalities play a significant part in the whole event, but as far as I'm concerned, a live match could have anyone communicating or doing the punditry, it's the game that I watch and I never listen to anything any of them say anyway.
You say that until you get a Sam Matterface doing live commentary being absolutely unbearable.
You say that until you get a Sam Matterface doing live commentary being absolutely unbearable.
Yeah he is distractingly bad. I remember Jonathan pearces first game on channel 5 - must be 20 years ago now. Both of them suffer from verbal diarrhoea, they are basically the idiot in the pub who has to fill every second with a comment even though they are the least interesting and least intelligent person there.
Most commentators are decent though. If you don’t notice them, they are doing a good job. Although I do get fed up with some (radio wales in particular) who forget we can’t see the game. “It’s a goal!” Is useless- we need “Cardiff have scored!”
I’ve not watched the jeff stelling thing for years but that’s just because I don’t care about football outside of ccfc any more. When I did watch it, I thought he was excellent. Professional but warm, enthusiastic but not (normally) hyperbolic. He must have been doing that show for 20 years though, so surely time for a change.
I think Nicholas, Le Tissier and Thompson were past it for a variety of reasons, but I’d be surprised if the changes were down to any significant drop in audience. Sky had been bringing others into their positions for a long time, especially on the midweek shows.
It could be that the show’s viewing figures have decreased as the internet has become more and more interactive, and so much more football-related content is now available online, and of course there are also the BBC and BT alternatives now.
Whatever is the case, I hope the show continues in the same or at least a very similar format once Stelling has moved on. I thoroughly enjoy it, and more so in recent years than ever before. The programme is one of many reasons I can never see myself going back to being a full-time City supporter. Watching Soccer Saturday is often more entertaining and enjoyable than going to games and it’s a lot less hassle too.
Not supporting the BLM badges was reported as one issue around Le Tissier, and his outspoken views
I won’t miss him . Overrated presenter whom Sky overpaid. I could read the scores off an autocue and sound more interesting.
I remember when he had a Hartlepool shirt on , during a crucial relegation day . A complete fool. Glad Newport stayed up that year. Get shot of him, and get someone in his chair who’ s not plastic ,but knowledgeable and interesting at the same time. In other words , someone with a bit of class .
You are entitled to your opinion.
My opinion is you’re talking bollox.
Comment