Genesis

[Tuerto]

Re: Genesis

“I’m no music aficionado” is absolutely spot on. You obviously have no idea what you are talking about. This is one of the greatest bands ever ,who have been very successful for over 50 years. Next time you go shopping, buy yourself some milk that won’t curdle. You do not stay at the top of your business if you have no talent. Please do not insult this band any more.

**** me, keep your hair on Ivor. I didn't say that they weren't talented.

[Feedback]

Re: Genesis

“I’m no music aficionado” is absolutely spot on. You obviously have no idea what you are talking about. This is one of the greatest bands ever ,who have been very successful for over 50 years. Next time you go shopping, buy yourself some milk that won’t curdle. You do not stay at the top of your business if you have no talent. Please do not insult this band any more.

I have no idea what defines a music aficionada but I watch a lot of live music (last night I watched Odd Morris in M/cr and tonight I'm off to watch the OCs, next week I've got Working Mens Club and Porridge Radio, the week after is Shame and then the Liines - you get the idea), and quite frankly selling a lot of records does not imply you're any good whatsoever. in fact, the more records you sell, the more you move away from what you were in the beginning and start producing music that sells, and not music that you want to make.

Genesis are ****ing gash, utter drivel, a muzak make machine. the only good thing to come out of Phil Collins was the jizz that made Lily.

[ToTaL ITK]

Re: Genesis

I have no idea what defines a music aficionada but I watch a lot of live music (last night I watched Odd Morris in M/cr and tonight I'm off to watch the OCs, next week I've got Working Mens Club and Porridge Radio, the week after is Shame and then the Liines - you get the idea), and quite frankly selling a lot of records does not imply you're any good whatsoever. in fact, the more records you sell, the more you move away from what you were in the beginning and start producing music that sells, and not music that you want to make.

Genesis are ****ing gash, utter drivel, a muzak make machine. the only good thing to come out of Phil Collins was the jizz that made Lily.

In your opinion! and what you say in your first paragraph there is some sense.But prog is about musicianship. ELP nothing for me but individually they are super musicians...the same goes for yes and genesis and king crimson. Pink fFoyd are blues based and frank Zappa more fusion jazz. Different strokes for different folks

[Feedback]

Re: Genesis

In your opinion! and what you say in your first paragraph there is some sense.But prog is about musicianship. ELP nothing for me but individually they are super musicians...the same goes for yes and genesis and king crimson. Pink fFoyd are blues based and frank Zappa more fusion jazz. Different strokes for different folks

Well yes of course its my opinion. I prefer finding new music than listening to the same band over and over. There's few bands who make an album better than their first. They played those first songs over many years, honing the songs until they were right. The 2nd album has no such luxury as its usually rushed to market at the behest of the record label

[SLUDGE FACTORY]

Re: Genesis

Sabbath

Metal

Have it

Close the book

Bring out your dead 💀

[life on mars]

Re: Genesis

Bloody crap

Been trying to listen to them after seeing so many people go to see them

Don't get it

One of most overrated bands of all time

Dreadful, they managed to convince all the LCD pot heads they were good poor man's ELP, YES, Floyd.

[The Bloop]

Re: Genesis

Sabbath

Metal

Have it

Close the book

Bring out your dead 💀

It's far too obvious that all this metal talk is just a front and you've really been listening to the new ABBA album all day 🙂

[ToTaL ITK]

Re: Genesis

Well yes of course its my opinion. I prefer finding new music than listening to the same band over and over. There's few bands who make an album better than their first. They played those first songs over many years, honing the songs until they were right. The 2nd album has no such luxury as its usually rushed to market at the behest of the record label

Been in that position myself...of course your first materiel is the best...maybe not the best produced so the second album does well due to better production...then the third is hit and miss...The police are a great example

[SLUDGE FACTORY]

Re: Genesis

It's far too obvious that all this metal talk is just a front and you've really been listening to the new ABBA album all day 🙂

Take a chance on me , unstoppable pop

Imagine that with chainsaw guitars 🎸

[Feedback]

Re: Genesis

Been in that position myself...of course your first materiel is the best...maybe not the best produced so the second album does well due to better production...then the third is hit and miss...The police are a great example

You get it, this is spot on.

Anyway, the OCs were great tonight, proper psychedelic rock with a bit of closet prog rock

[kendoddsdadsdogsdead]

Re: Genesis

Oh look at that bird on Mrs coldtarts roof !

....put your foreskin over your head

[dml1954]

Re: Genesis

I have no idea what defines a music aficionada but I watch a lot of live music (last night I watched Odd Morris in M/cr and tonight I'm off to watch the OCs, next week I've got Working Mens Club and Porridge Radio, the week after is Shame and then the Liines - you get the idea), and quite frankly selling a lot of records does not imply you're any good whatsoever. in fact, the more records you sell, the more you move away from what you were in the beginning and start producing music that sells, and not music that you want to make.

Genesis are ****ing gash, utter drivel, a muzak make machine. the only good thing to come out of Phil Collins was the jizz that made Lily.

Why be so offensive ? No doubt loads of people (including me) think that the stuff you listen to is utter, tuneless and talentless, crap. Collins and the rest have had a 50 year successful career at the top and still fill large venues whereas the people you mention will probably disappear without trace quite quickly.

[Pearcey3]

Re: Genesis

Just to write Genesis off as crap is a bit daft. Their work is so varied. Trespass is massively different from The Lamb Lies down on Broadway. The Lamb Lies down on Broadway is nothing like Duke etc.
I’m no Collins fan but a big PG fan. However they kept going under Collins and became more successful.

[Pearcey3]

Re: Genesis

Just to add they are proper musicians too. Hackett is one of the finest guitarists around. Collins one of the best drummers in his prime. Hardly crap.

[jimmyscoular]

Re: Genesis

Bloody crap

Been trying to listen to them after seeing so many people go to see them

Don't get it

One of most overrated bands of all time

Went to see Kansas once (free tickets). They had two songs. The rest of the time reminded me either of crockery breaking against the wall during a barney with the missus or a chainsaw cutting through metal.