I thought Giles was by far the best for us out of those loanees.
Honourary mention for Niels Nkounkou, who I really rated even if nobody else did.
Printable View
Did you see the goal Doncaster scored against Hull on Sunday - Giles’ defensive shortcomings captured within the space of a few seconds. Nkounkou was similar to Giles as he couldn’t defend either, both were good with the ball though - Giles with his crossing and N’Kounkou with his ability to go past opponents.