Good point :thumbup:
Worrying times
Printable View
Keep up.
A nazi is someone who wants an inquiry into child grooming, someone who thinks Israel deserves to exist and someone who their opponent doesn't want to debate with anymore so they use it as a get out clause.
It is also a member of the now defunct NSDAP German National Socialist Workers Party, who haven't been taking members for 80 years now, but why let the truth get in the way of a good story!?
Musk on tour!
https://www.theguardian.com/technolo...astern-germany
Each day it's getting a bit harder to fight that corner, isn't it?
https://www.politico.com/news/2025/0...eidel-00200620
No it isn't. That's what a Nazi is.
Surely you don't think Germans now should keep apologizing for crimes from 80 years ago? In which case every country would be apologizing for all of their history wouldnt they?
I'm something of a Germanophile, inch liebe Deutchsland, and in my experience they are extremely aware of the grotesque crimes that happened in the past. More so than some countries tbh.
You are correct that words should be used carefully.
Sometimes they are used very loosely - which annoys me. Words have meanings. There may be some scope to argue over the meaning but in these cases (across the political and social spectrum) they are too often just adopted as labels of abuse.
However, you and James and the Tommy Hipster (and Life On Mars when he was with us) go to the other extreme - and (Musk-like) deny any validity to thoughtfully used words that define political ideology or practice. You gut the language of meaning by denial instead of over-use. Just as bad!
Rightly or wrongly, Musk is addressing the German people because he thinks the only other outcome will be a totalitarian AI surveillance state, and yes, it really is that simple.
BTW, if you mean Russia collusion, Hunter Biden Laptop, and the wet market covid origin, then I plead guilty!
Stewart Lee using the fascist tag a bit loosely, but it's for comic effect (and very effective, and very funny) so it's allowed!
https://www.theguardian.com/commenti...an-unholy-mess
Not sure you can realistically claim to be annoyed by the loose use of language and then in the very next paragraph accuse people of having "extreme" position.
You used my name so please point out where I taken anything to an extreme?
I've stated the literal meaning of a Nazi. Theres other language people can use but Nazi is very specific.
I've also said that no, I don't think Elon Musk is a fascist or a neo Nazi. Thats an opinion based on balance not selective information and it most certainly is not an extreme opinion in any way whatsoever.