-
Re: Club respond to open letter
Quote:
Originally Posted by
blue matt
I wonder if you spoke to a reading fan about how its gone for them since that game ( and I have ) I wonder if they would swap places with you
You take one line of a long post of mine and seek to make a completely pointless argument which has nothing whatsoever to do with what the message was about :facepalm:. What are your thoughts about the owner of the club making a series of decisions over a decade or more that make it much harder for him to get a return on his, considerable, investment?
-
Re: Club respond to open letter
Quote:
Originally Posted by
blue matt
I wonder if you spoke to a reading fan about how its gone for them since that game ( and I have ) I wonder if they would swap places with you
I wonder if you spoke to any Wolves, Fulham, Villa or Brentford fans since our Championship games against them in 2017/18 whether they would swap places with you?
That’s about as relevant.
-
Re: Club respond to open letter
Quote:
Originally Posted by
blue matt
maybe not that absurd, people walked away when VT upset them once before :shrug:
You gave people not happy with the hierarchy at City two options, buy the club or walk away from it. I suppose that means you think every one still going to games should be like you - perfectly happy to see the team being beaten at home much more often than they win over a period of nearly four and a half seasons, perfectly happy to see the club having seven managers in four years (with a good chance that there’ll be another one before the season is over) and perfectly happy to see the club try to muddle through with a skeleton coaching staff and part timers occupying the senior administration positions. As I said, absurd.
-
Re: Club respond to open letter
Quote:
Originally Posted by
TWGL1
You find it impossible to contemplate that most of the fanbase don’t care about boardroom politics, ultimately if what you’re saying is so true why are the trust membership numbers staggeringly low ?
I don't think anyone has been talking about boardroom politics.
The concern/complaints have been about the lack of a club strategy or even a short-medium term plan; a lack of decision making around the manager position and the coaching staff, and a crap record on communicating with supporters (or customers if you and Matt prefer).
The board and the owner have every right to act the way they do. Fans have every right to be pissed off about it, and not to just walk away (or have a whip around and buy the club off Vincent).
-
Re: Club respond to open letter
Blue Twat Matt sums up everything wrong with this fanbase
-
Re: Club respond to open letter
I agree with much of what has been said in this thread: yes, most people don't care about "all that stuff that the owner deals with".
They want to simply turn up, see their friends, enjoy the match, and go home feeling they've had a great day out. They go to the football to forget about problems, not to have more problems to deal with.
But, there are other people who want to see the long-term security of the club being managed, so that everyone can continue to have those great days out. They are willing to ask the awkward questions. They are ready to remind those in charge of their responsibilities.
It's a damning indictment of our current fanbase that supporters who care - those who are trying to hold the club hierarchy to account - get shot at or ridiculed for caring.
It's another damning indictment of our current fanbase that we have people suggesting "if you don't like the way it's being run, then walk away".
-
Re: Club respond to open letter
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Crisp White Lines
I agree with much of what has been said in this thread: yes, most people don't care about "all that stuff that the owner deals with".
They want to simply turn up, see their friends, enjoy the match, and go home feeling they've had a great day out. They go to the football to forget about problems, not to have more problems to deal with.
But, there are other people who want to see the long-term security of the club being managed, so that everyone can continue to have those great days out. They are willing to ask the awkward questions. They are ready to remind those in charge of their responsibilities.
It's a damning indictment of our current fanbase that supporters who care - those who are trying to hold the club hierarchy to account - get shot at or ridiculed for caring.
It's another damning indictment of our current fanbase that we have people suggesting "if you don't like the way it's being run, then walk away".
Excellent post. Well said. Football often gets described as being soulless nowadays. That goes for some fans too.
-
Re: Club respond to open letter
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Crisp White Lines
It's a damning indictment of our current fanbase that supporters who care - those who are trying to hold the club hierarchy to account - get shot at or ridiculed for caring.
The sneering, dismissive attitude some Cardiff City supporters have towards the Trust and the other fans organisations would be disappointing if it wasn't so tediously predictable.
The fact of the matter is that supporters' groups have saved a number of high-profile British professional football clubs in the not-too-distant past. Clubs such as Brighton, Bournemouth, Luton, Swansea and Wrexham probably wouldn't exist now if their fans hadn't got themselves organised and done whatever was necessary when they were in trouble.
That means nothing to certain individuals, though. They'd much rather criticise and sneer at the fans who do get involved than ever do anything constructive themselves.
-
Re: Club respond to open letter
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Crisp White Lines
I agree with much of what has been said in this thread: yes, most people don't care about "all that stuff that the owner deals with".
They want to simply turn up, see their friends, enjoy the match, and go home feeling they've had a great day out. They go to the football to forget about problems, not to have more problems to deal with.
But, there are other people who want to see the long-term security of the club being managed, so that everyone can continue to have those great days out. They are willing to ask the awkward questions. They are ready to remind those in charge of their responsibilities.
It's a damning indictment of our current fanbase that supporters who care - those who are trying to hold the club hierarchy to account - get shot at or ridiculed for caring.
It's another damning indictment of our current fanbase that we have people suggesting "if you don't like the way it's being run, then walk away".
Good points well made.
It’s also pretty damning that after so many weeks of no communication from the club whatsoever all we get is a written critical response about not following some protocol. There were plenty of of opportunities in the past few weeks for one of the management to make a statement about the current managerial situation , even if it was just a holding statement
-
Re: Club respond to open letter
Quote:
Originally Posted by
The Lone Gunman
The sneering, dismissive attitude some Cardiff City supporters have towards the Trust and the other fans organisations would be disappointing if it wasn't so tediously predictable.
The fact of the matter is that supporters' groups have saved a number of high-profile British professional football clubs in the not-too-distant past. Clubs such as Brighton, Bournemouth, Luton, Swansea and Wrexham probably wouldn't exist now if their fans hadn't got themselves organised and done whatever was necessary when they were in trouble.
That means nothing to certain individuals, though. They'd much rather criticise and sneer at the fans who do get involved than ever do anything constructive themselves.
In reference to your last sentence, just to clarify, you’re the one who started with the snide comments regarding my initial post as did One or two others , what was is “ conspiracy “ and the like.
What have you done that’s helped the club more than me or supporters who don’t wish to be part of the trust ? I thought you were never watching them again and via various sources you slag off the club and its hierarchy almost daily for the last ten years or so - don’t you think that may put one or two casual fans off ?
Ive has corporate season tickets , and normal season tickets for the last 25 years, bought around £1,000 worth of crappy merchandise for my son per season since he was born , had him a mascot on numerous occasions and attended various off the field events. No big deal , people similar to me do the same and just get on with supporting the club year on year regardless of who’s running it.
Clearly, judging by the trust numbers compared to average gate , it’s a pathway the vast majority of supporters are just not interested in.
-
Re: Club respond to open letter
Quote:
Originally Posted by
TWGL1
What have you done that’s helped the club more than me or supporters who don’t wish to be part of the trust ?
Nothing. And I've made no claims of that nature.
-
Re: Club respond to open letter
Quote:
Originally Posted by
TWGL1
What have you done that’s helped the club more than me or supporters who don’t wish to be part of the trust ?
Incidentally, I'm not a member of the Trust and haven't been since 2012.
-
Re: Club respond to open letter
Quote:
Originally Posted by
TWGL1
In reference to your last sentence, just to clarify, you’re the one who started with the snide comments regarding my initial post as did One or two others , what was is “ conspiracy “ and the like.
What have you done that’s helped the club more than me or supporters who don’t wish to be part of the trust ? I thought you were never watching them again and via various sources you slag off the club and its hierarchy almost daily for the last ten years or so - don’t you think that may put one or two casual fans off ?
Ive has corporate season tickets , and normal season tickets for the last 25 years, bought around £1,000 worth of crappy merchandise for my son per season since he was born , had him a mascot on numerous occasions and attended various off the field events. No big deal , people similar to me do the same and just get on with supporting the club year on year regardless of who’s running it.
Clearly, judging by the trust numbers compared to average gate , it’s a pathway the vast majority of supporters are just not interested in.
You spend £1000 per season on merch for your son?! Surely not, do you mean overall since he's been born?
-
Re: Club respond to open letter
Who wouldn't want to watch a Brewsters Millions style show where someone attempts to spend a grand a year in the club shop.
-
Re: Club respond to open letter
Quote:
Originally Posted by
lardy
Who wouldn't want to watch a Brewsters Millions style show where someone attempts to spend a grand a year in the club shop.
That's a lot of paperweights!
-
Re: Club respond to open letter
Training tops , three kits , beach towels per year training tops and home and away kits for family members for Xmas year on year ( niece and nephews x 5) , footballs , hats and scarves, and three programmes per home game - how much does all that add up
-
Re: Club respond to open letter
Quote:
Originally Posted by
TWGL1
Training tops , three kits , beach towels per year training tops and home and away kits for family members for Xmas year on year ( niece and nephews x 5) , footballs , hats and scarves, and three programmes per home game - how much does all that add up
My maths ain't great, but it sounds to me like that adds up to a lot more than one son.
-
Re: Club respond to open letter
Quote:
Originally Posted by
The Lone Gunman
My maths ain't great, but it sounds to me like that adds up to a lot more than one son.
The total spent ,which before tax is around the figure quoted ,it may differ by a few hundred pounds ( gross ) per year but shall we just continue with the current thread rather than scrutinise my gross expenditure ?
Typically it’s going off track again just because that what posters tend to do just to make a point usually not relevant to actual content of discussion
-
Re: Club respond to open letter
Quote:
Originally Posted by
TWGL1
Typically it’s going off track again just because that what posters tend to do just to make a point usually not relevant to actual content of discussion
In fairness, you made a startling claim to have spent £1,000 a year on City merchandise for your son every year since he was born. It's hardly surprising people picked up on it.
I answered your question in an earlier post.
:thumbup:
-
Re: Club respond to open letter
Quote:
Originally Posted by
TWGL1
The total spent ,which before tax is around the figure quoted ,it may differ by a few hundred pounds ( gross ) per year but shall we just continue with the current thread rather than scrutinise my gross expenditure ?
Typically it’s going off track again just because that what posters tend to do just to make a point usually not relevant to actual content of discussion
You said you spent a grand a year on merch on your son, which seemed mindblowing to me having seen the club shop. Makes a lot more sense if it was on all those other people as well, but I do worry about what's happening to all the beach towels.
But anyway, like you said, on with the original thread topic
-
Re: Club respond to open letter
Quote:
Originally Posted by
The Lone Gunman
In fairness, you made a startling claim to have spent £1,000 a year on City merchandise for your son every year since he was born. It's hardly surprising people picked up on it.
I answered your question in an earlier post.
:thumbup:
To be honest some seasons I’ve spent insane amounts , especially after a decent win , doesn’t everyone ?
-
Re: Club respond to open letter
Quote:
Originally Posted by
TWGL1
To be honest some seasons I’ve spent insane amounts , especially after a decent win , doesn’t everyone ?
Not me. Never was much of a club shop man, even during the days when I was fully engaged with the club. The odd scarf here and there perhaps, a polo shirt once in while (usually in the end of season sale) and that's about it really.
I'm surprised you are to be honest given some of your posts about clothes, etc.
-
Re: Club respond to open letter
In the last two days, I’ve watched three City podcasts and read this piece.
https://www.dai-sport.com/cardiff-ci...ut-themselves/
There’s a common theme between them - they were all produced by people who, according to some on here, need to either buy the club or walk away.
-
Re: Club respond to open letter
Quote:
Originally Posted by
The Lone Gunman
Not me. Never was much of a club shop man, even during the days when I was fully engaged with the club. The odd scarf here and there perhaps, a polo shirt once in while (usually in the end of season sale) and that's about it really.
I'm surprised you are to be honest given some of your posts about clothes, etc.
I am partial to training gear for around the house ( lounge wear ) or popping to the supermarket etc
-
Re: Club respond to open letter
Quote:
Originally Posted by
TWGL1
How does he make money out of the football club , around 80% of all professional football clubs make significant loses ?
Without the owners financial support we would be wound up by the HMRC and we have almost been wound up under Hammam a few times, which people in this thread have simply forgotten
It's also true that he's needed to provide that financial support as we've been so rotten in bringing in players and managers.