Quote Originally Posted by Pedro de la Rosa View Post
We have to play this formation as we don't have a senior left back, and Bagan is the only other option.

Giles was our only outlet. We have zero pace in the side. Bagan and Ng aren't good enough going forwards to be wing backs, especially when our midfield is as pedestrian as it is. It also doesn't suit any of our centre halves, perhaps only Flint. I absolutely hate this formation, we've been bloody dreadful in it.

We also are playing better but in terms of results, it isn't that outstanding. I'm pretty sure we can play good football in a back 4. Especially when Nelson can't pass water, we're trying to play possession football with centre halves that aren't capable of doing so. We can also be hard to beat. Most teams play 3 up front, so with a back 4 you should have a spare man. It can be difficult in a 3/5, especially when centre halves are getting dragged out wide.
We were crap in a back 4 before Mccarthy got here, and I don't think we would be any better now.

Since Morison took over we have 12 points from 10 games. not great, but if that is maintained it would be enough to keep us clear of trouble most probably.

Giles will be a big miss, but we will either have to bring in a replacement or find a way to have another outlet - I don't think it calls for completely changing the formation.