Andy Carroll?

[B. Oddie]

Would you be happy?

[stevo]

No

[MacAdder]

On a pay per game basis he could be a useful acquisition though I would expect to see him on the injury table more often than not.

[celticknight]

Considering he just failed a medical which saw a move to Club Brugge fall through, all he'll do here is sit on the physio's table.

[fred keenor]

Considering he just failed a medical which saw a move to Club Brugge fall through, all he'll do here is sit on the physio's table.

Pay as you play tho

[2b2bdoo]

I think he would be great but obviously injuries are an issue.

[Undercoverinwurzelland]

No thanks. Don't think that fits in at all with what we're trying to do now does it? Pretty desperate.

[Rjk]

would give us an option, but how many games would we realistically get out of him?

[Chris Pontprennau Blues]

only if he gets a hair cut

[Pearcey3]

He was terrific for us last season. Worth a gamble.

[Citizen's Nephew]

Considering he just failed a medical which saw a move to Club Brugge fall through, all he'll do here is sit on the physio's table.

Exactly.

[PontBlue]

Can't see him passing a medical but would be a good option on a pay as you play contract as he'd give us something different and wouldn't command a transfer fee.

[blue matt]

pay as he plays, yea sure, nice option to have for 20 mins of the game

[2b2bdoo]

He was terrific for us last season. Worth a gamble.

That’s my thought, despite his injuries he seemed pretty mobile and liked to get stuck in? I think he would add another dimension to us.

[NYCBlue]

Absolutely not!

[B. Oddie]

After seeing the performance today, I'm not sure a massive, but injury-prone CF is what we need this season.

[UNDERHILL1927]

We definitely need someone on the end of our crosses in the box, Andy isn’t the answer though

[Pearcey3]

That’s my thought, despite his injuries he seemed pretty mobile and liked to get stuck in? I think he would add another dimension to us.

Yep he got stuck in and was very hard working. Probably our best player alongside Swift during the period he was with us.

[chris lee]

Hard to say no, incredibly talented player

[City123]

Can he get on the pitch? He's talented but his body's f*cked!

Doesn't really line up with what Dalman was saying regarding one loan and one fee

[Elwood Blues]

He was terrific for us last season. Worth a gamble.

Yes on a pay as you play basis he is worth a punt.

I saw somewhere that he didn't get a massive salary off Reading either.

Do you know Pearcey?

[Pearcey3]

Yes on a pay as you play basis he is worth a punt.

I saw somewhere that he didn't get a massive salary off Reading either.

Do you know Pearcey?

A grand a week.

[Rock_Flock_of_Five]

Hard to say no, incredibly talented player

Oh c'mon!
A sense of perspective, please.
A player like Bale, is/was "incredibly talented" - Andy Carroll has talent, nothing more, nothing less.

[Alan Lung]

A grand a week.

****ing hell, that's less than Newport County players are on.

[chris lee]

Oh c'mon!
A sense of perspective, please.
A player like Bale, is/was "incredibly talented" - Andy Carroll has talent, nothing more, nothing less.

aha I suppose we all have different scales

I would describe Jay Bothroyd as talented, Andy Carrol as incredibly talented, and Bale as world class