The Manics

[Wales-Bales]

Where did it all go wrong?

[Wales-Bales]

Re: The Manics

[SLUDGE FACTORY]

Re: The Manics

Over rated band

Some good tunes , Kevin Carter , Motorcycle Emptiness being prime examples but not consistent

The millennium gig they did was one of the most boring concerts I have ever been to not helped by thousands of thicko taffs in Welsh rugby tops pissed out of their minds

The Super Furries were OK though

[Wales-Bales]

Re: The Manics

Over rated band

Some good tunes , Kevin Carter , Motorcycle Emptiness being prime examples but not consistent

The millennium gig they did was one of the most boring concerts I have ever been to not helped by thousands of thicko taffs in Welsh rugby tops pissed out of their minds

The Super Furries were OK though

They started off good, but I went off them fairly quickly.

[NYCBlue]

Re: The Manics

They started off good, but I went off them fairly quickly.

This. Vastly overrated. And mostly boring.

[Ivortheengine]

Re: The Manics

For me, it was. Design For Life and that’s it.

[Bruce Parry]

Re: The Manics

They were never going to make another Holy Bible without Richie. I’d argue Holy Bible is one of the best albums of the 90s.

[superfeathers]

Re: The Manics

A superb band and excellent live even now.
I find that people who slag them off often haven’t scratched the surface

[Whisperer]

Re: The Manics

I tried hard but they’re not for me.

[Father Dougal]

Re: The Manics

A superb band and excellent live even now.
I find that people who slag them off often haven’t scratched the surface

No surface all feeling.

I find people who like the manics really like the manics. A cult band perhaps.

I'd never debate who is better or what's good as it's completely personal but to me the manics are the greatest band of all time and pretty much the only band I listen to.

(Ps can not believe Sludge hasn't commented yet that the band support forest, spurs and Liverpool but he can use that as another stick to beat them with)

[Harry Lime]

Re: The Manics

Thought the Holy Bible was a great album. Didn't mind the comeback initially but they should have packed it in years ago. Credit to them for getting to number one with a song about the Spanish Civil War.

[SLUDGE FACTORY]

Re: The Manics

No surface all feeling.

I find people who like the manics really like the manics. A cult band perhaps.

I'd never debate who is better or what's good as it's completely personal but to me the manics are the greatest band of all time and pretty much the only band I listen to.

(Ps can not believe Sludge hasn't commented yet that the band support forest, spurs and Liverpool but he can use that as another stick to beat them with)

Well for that they are complete fakes

I mean hanging Welsh flags over your speakers playing gigs but supporting English football teams ?

It's embarrassing

[Father Dougal]

Re: The Manics

Well for that they are complete fakes

I mean hanging Welsh flags over your speakers playing gigs but supporting English football teams ?

It's embarrassing

:hehe:

[SLUDGE FACTORY]

Re: The Manics

:hehe:

It is ff sake

Bloody English......we are so proud to be Welsh.......have you seen my spurs top ?

[Brizzlebluebirds]

Re: The Manics

No surface all feeling.

(Ps can not believe Sludge hasn't commented yet that the band support forest, spurs and Liverpool but he can use that as another stick to beat them with)

It was the secret he had missed.:getscoat: