Championship attendances this weekend

[TWGL1]

Re: Championship attendances this weekend

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_o...United_Kingdom

Please read this

It's about the best explanation of the size of Newcastle, Nottingham and Cardiff urban areas

The figures given by some people on here about a Cardiff urban population of 1.1 million people include Newport which itself has an urban area of 300 k

The urban areas around Newcastle itself than make up an urban population of 823k are joined at the hip to Newcastle......Gateshead, North Shields , North Tyne side

You can't expect people to include Barry and Bridgend as part of greater Cardiff

That's why Newcastle has a bigger urban area than Cardiff . It's not about opinions , it's based on population data .

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ESPON_metropolitan_areas_in_the_United_Kingdom

Barry and Penarth and are not part of the urban area of 1,000,097 , so you could argue it’s much bigger as both places should be

Bridgend is also around 140k not 24,000 so it could be bigger still

[Tuerto]

Re: Championship attendances this weekend

We have played top flight football twice in the past 60 years or so. Spent 20 years dying on our arses in a decaying stadium, better known for for football related violence that what happened on the playing field. Since going up to the championship we've been half decent, and apart from Dave Jones' sides (sporadically) and Warnocks for about 3-4 months, the football has been pretty shit. Another important factor is how a community is formed, and how a football club becomes the pivot within that Community, Cardiff have never been that. An interesting study would be why some football clubs get such fantastic support when they haven't been that successful, but it seems that the club is entwined within the culture of the Town or City.

[goats]

Re: Championship attendances this weekend

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_o...United_Kingdom

Please read this

It's about the best explanation of the size of Newcastle, Nottingham and Cardiff urban areas

The figures given by some people on here about a Cardiff urban population of 1.1 million people include Newport which itself has an urban area of 300 k

The urban areas around Newcastle itself than make up an urban population of 823k are joined at the hip to Newcastle......Gateshead, North Shields , North Tyne side

You can't expect people to include Barry and Bridgend as part of greater Cardiff

That's why Newcastle has a bigger urban area than Cardiff . It's not about opinions , it's based on population data .

I see that, there is no gap, it’s one city really in my mind if there are no gaps….

[Sloop_Jon_Bee]

Re: Championship attendances this weekend

They were also one of the more successful clubs in the late 70s and early 80s, more successful than we've ever been. Families keep supporting the club. They never lost a generation while bobbing about in the bottom division. We're still recovering from that.

Not disagreeing with that Eric. Big club, bigger than than us i agree and i remember them being among the best teams in the 70s and 80s But they have not been more successful than us in past 20 years.
Spedger

[goats]

Re: Championship attendances this weekend

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ESPON_...United_Kingdom

Barry and Penarth and are not part of the urban area of 1,000,097 , so you could argue it’s much bigger as both places should be

That’s crazy, penarth is basically a suburb, there’s no real gap and it’s closer to the centre than many parts of cardiff.

[SLUDGE FACTORY]

Re: Championship attendances this weekend

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tyneside#/media/File%3ATynesideBUA.png

That's a map of the Newcastle urban area , tyneside

Unless you are blind you can see the reason why Newcastle.....greater Newcastle, urban Newcastle......whatever you want to call it is far bigger in area and population than Cardiff

If you just take Newcastle, Gateshead and Wallsend you have a population bigger than Cardiff

If you want to try and pretend Barry and Pontypridd and the valleys and Newport are part of Cardiff and make a possible catchment area of 1 million people go ahead

There is no gap of green fields and countryside between Newcastle and Whitley Bay......its a continuous urban sprawl along the banks of the Tyne

It's a very heavily populated area close to one million people ....without the need of satellite towns to boost its size , unlike Cardiff

[SLUDGE FACTORY]

Re: Championship attendances this weekend

That’s crazy, penarth is basically a suburb, there’s no real gap and it’s closer to the centre than many parts of cardiff.

Penarth is about 35 thousand people . It's no Gateshead which is stuck to Newcastle like glue and has 200000 residents .

[splott parker]

Re: Championship attendances this weekend

The metropolitan population of Cardiff at 1 .1 million includes the population of Newport, 12 miles away 200 k .....Bridgend , 130 k .....18 miles away ....and much of the south wales valleys

Since when is Newport and Bridgend and Aberdare and Merthyr part of urban Cardiff ?

There is clearly a built up , continuous urban zone around Newcastle and Nottingham which makes them far bigger centres of population than Cardiff

The Cardiff urban area of around 450 k is clearly smaller than Newcastle at 823 k and Nottingham at 807 k

If you are going to use the metropolitan definition of Cardiff .....which includes 200000 people from Newport in its total ......ask them if they are from Cardiff ......then the large urban areas close to Nottingham have to be included , like Derby and Mansfield ......making Nottingham even bigger again

Metropolitan means the extent or influence of a city , the urban population is different and refers to the immediate built up areas where districts , suburbs and towns merge

Bridgend clearly isn't a part of urban Cardiff .....there are fields and meadows and cows for 18 miles between the settlements ......yet for administrative and cultural and employments it's part of if you wish .....greater Cardiff ?

But Nottingham and Newcastle have a big urban population surrounding them for several miles ....which is why they are seen as bigger cities than Cardiff even though their populations initially seem smaller

If you wander around Newcastle or Nottingham , visit the train stations , see the buildings it's obvious they serve a bigger population than Cardiff

Hope this explains things

👍

Crewe must be massive if you’re going by railway stations Train stations are bugger all to go by, most main ones were built years and years ago with no room for expansion in their locations when populations have increased. You’ve more or less hit the nail on the head decrying outlying areas because they’re subjective. Therefore Newcastle is a touch larger than Sunderland but not as big as Cardiff, the population & km2 areas are there for all to see.

[SLUDGE FACTORY]

Re: Championship attendances this weekend

Crewe must be massive if you’re going by railway stations Train stations are bugger all to go by, most main ones were built years and years ago with no room for expansion in their locations when populations have increased. You’ve more or less hit the nail on the head decrying outlying areas because they’re subjective. Therefore Newcastle is a touch larger than Sunderland but not as big as Cardiff, the population & km2 areas are there for all to see.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cardiff_urban_area

Here is a map of the Cardiff urban area

It's about half the size and half the population of the Newcastle urban area

Newcastle merges South with Gateshead and then inland along the Tyne to form a densely populated area

Cardiff could be argued to merge with penarth but certainly not pontypridd and apart from the town of Caerphilly the rest of the valleys do not join Cardiff directly

To say that what people think of as " Newcastle " is twice the size of what people think as " Cardiff " is about right

Newcastle has a big arena , a bigger city centre , more night time entertainment , a big Chinatown, its bigger in every way

I would love our city and football team to have bigger crowds , be a better team , have more music venues , etc

But it just isn't as big and progressive as Leeds , Sheffield , Nottingham , Bristol etc

Just the way it is

[TWGL1]

Re: Championship attendances this weekend

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cardiff_urban_area

Here is a map of the Cardiff urban area

It's about half the size and half the population of the Newcastle urban area

Newcastle merges South with Gateshead and then inland along the Tyne to form a densely populated area

Cardiff could be argued to merge with penarth but certainly not pontypridd and apart from the town of Caerphilly the rest of the valleys do not join Cardiff directly

To say that what people think of as " Newcastle " is twice the size of what people think as " Cardiff " is about right

Newcastle has a big arena , a bigger city centre , more night time entertainment , a big Chinatown, its bigger in every way

I would love our city and football team to have bigger crowds , be a better team , have more music venues , etc

But it just isn't as big and progressive as Leeds , Sheffield , Nottingham , Bristol etc

Just the way it is

I don’t think your map is to scale

Cardiff excels in many areas particularly sports.

Champions League finals , Olympic venues, Test Cricket , Cardiff singer of the World , European Summit , Rugby World Cup Venue , Euro championship venue 2028 superb hotels etc etc

Much better than Newcastle - it’s a backwater

It outperforms many cities in the UK

[splott parker]

Re: Championship attendances this weekend

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cardiff_urban_area

Here is a map of the Cardiff urban area

It's about half the size and half the population of the Newcastle urban area

Newcastle merges South with Gateshead and then inland along the Tyne to form a densely populated area

Cardiff could be argued to merge with penarth but certainly not pontypridd and apart from the town of Caerphilly the rest of the valleys do not join Cardiff directly

To say that what people think of as " Newcastle " is twice the size of what people think as " Cardiff " is about right

Newcastle has a big arena , a bigger city centre , more night time entertainment , a big Chinatown, its bigger in every way

I would love our city and football team to have bigger crowds , be a better team , have more music venues , etc

But it just isn't as big and progressive as Leeds , Sheffield , Nottingham , Bristol etc

Just the way it is

Cardiff is bigger than Newcastle, 140 square kilometres to 114 square kilometres, it’s as simple as that. If you’ve driven across both cities you’ll realise that, getting from the West End to just past Chillingham Rd is a breeze compared to Culverhouse Cross to St. Mellon’s. Google it Sludge, it’s all there in black and white.

[SLUDGE FACTORY]

Re: Championship attendances this weekend

I don’t think your map is to scale

Cardiff excels in many areas particularly sports.

Champions League finals , Olympic venues, Test Cricket , Cardiff singer of the World , European Summit , Rugby World Cup Venue , Euro championship venue 2028 superb hotels etc etc

Much better than Newcastle - it’s a backwater

It outperforms many cities in the UK

Those maps give a good idea of why greater Newcastle is twice the size of greater Cardiff

Unless you are not able to read or are blind

[TWGL1]

Re: Championship attendances this weekend

Cardiff is bigger than Newcastle, 140 square kilometres to 114 square kilometres, it’s as simple as that. If you’ve driven across both cities you’ll realise that, getting from the West End to just past Chillingham Rd is a breeze compared to Culverhouse Cross to St. Mellon’s. Google it Sludge, it’s all there in black and white.

A Swans fan of mine told me recently he was astonished how much of an urban sprawl Cardiff was compared to Swansea and how much it’s expanded in a short time

[SLUDGE FACTORY]

Re: Championship attendances this weekend

Cardiff is bigger than Newcastle, 140 square kilometres to 114 square kilometres, it’s as simple as that. If you’ve driven across both cities you’ll realise that, getting from the West End to just past Chillingham Rd is a breeze compared to Culverhouse Cross to St. Mellon’s. Google it Sludge, it’s all there in black and white.

I really don't want to waste any more of my time with you on this matter

If you think as a cardiffian that the place you live is bigger than geordie land you are completely deluded or on a wind up

Enjoy your evening

[SLUDGE FACTORY]

Re: Championship attendances this weekend

A Swans fan of mine told me recently he was astonished how much of an urban sprawl Cardiff was compared to Swansea and how much it’s expanded in a short time

Oh well there we go then

Never mind the official statistics if some bloke from a small city in West Wales thinks Cardiff is huge we will go with that