Which would you rather?

[Rjk]

For the coming season...

[Rjk]

Re: Which would you rather?

option 1 :

We finish about 12th again, but the younger players are given a real go. Colwill, Ashford and Davies emerge as top championship players and one or to others also impress.

Option 2

We sign a load of battle hardened veterans and scrape into 6th (where we are outclassed 3-0 in the playoff semis). Opportunities for the younger players are very limited.

[the other bob wilson]

Re: Which would you rather?

option 1 :

We finish about 12th again, but the younger players are given a real go. Colwill, Ashford and Davies emerge as top championship players and one or to others also impress.

Option 2

We sign a load of battle hardened veterans and scrape into 6th (where we are outclassed 3-0 in the playoff semis). Opportunities for the younger players are very limited.

Think option 2 would be better in the long term.

[Rjk]

Re: Which would you rather?

Think option 2 would be better in the long term.

that's interesting, I think option 1 is better for the long term,

[North Cardiff Blue]

Re: Which would you rather?

option 1 :

We finish about 12th again, but the younger players are given a real go. Colwill, Ashford and Davies emerge as top championship players and one or to others also impress.

Option 2

We sign a load of battle hardened veterans and scrape into 6th (where we are outclassed 3-0 in the playoff semis). Opportunities for the younger players are very limited.

Option 3 - we get a bit of both and go up via the playoffs, Tan sells to a Saudi Trillionaire and we win back the £110million Sala money.

Bulut is hailed a genius, with free-flowing attack-minded football and TLG TOBW and ETHB (the miserable three) have to eat a shed load of humble pie

[Bluebirdman Of Alcathays]

Re: Which would you rather?

Option 1. Option 2 just means 2 more games of rather dull football, a little extra capital to spend on more battle hardened players and lots of articles about "progress".

[Rjk]

Re: Which would you rather?

Option 1. Option 2 just means 2 more games of rather dull football, a little extra capital to spend on more battle hardened players and lots of articles about "progress".

yeah that's my thinking really.
option 1 gives us the core of a team that will either continue to improve with us or can be sold for good money, and will likely be on lower wages

option 2 gives us the illusion of progress, but we are still in the same division just now with no youth coming through, and ageing players on big wages

[Hilts]

Re: Which would you rather?

Think option 2 would be better in the long term.

????? Have u made a typing error.🤣

Surely option 1 is better long term.

Anyway option 1 for me.

[North Cardiff Blue]

Re: Which would you rather?

yeah that's my thinking really.
option 1 gives us the core of a team that will either continue to improve with us or can be sold for good money, and will likely be on lower wages

option 2 gives us the illusion of progress, but we are still in the same division just now with no youth coming through, and ageing players on big wages

That's why we need a bit of both, i'd like to see progression and some youngsters coming through but they can't be fully relied on yet that's why we got spanked in the last few games.

[the other bob wilson]

Re: Which would you rather?

that's interesting, I think option 1 is better for the long term,

Sorry, I wasn’t concentrating- I meant option 1.

[Hilts]

Re: Which would you rather?

Sorry, I wasn’t concentrating- I meant option 1.

🤣👍

[Sparticus_Mills]

Re: Which would you rather?

Option 1 all day. We'd have something to build on and at worst some high value potential transfers.

[RichardM]

Re: Which would you rather?

Option 3 - we get a bit of both and go up via the playoffs, Tan sells to a Saudi Trillionaire and we win back the £110million Sala money.

Bulut is hailed a genius, with free-flowing attack-minded football and TLG TOBW and ETHB (the miserable three) have to eat a shed load of humble pie

It's not often that I agree with you, but I like your option 3

Assuming option 3 won't happen I'll go with 1

[North Cardiff Blue]

Re: Which would you rather?

It's not often that I agree with you, but I like your option 3

Assuming option 3 won't happen I'll go with 1

Yes me too, if it's only one or two it has to be one

[Carl Dale's Mole]

Re: Which would you rather?

Option 1 for me.

I've always believed we've underutilized our young talent.