Rumours doing the rounds

[Llandaff Blue]

Re: Rumours doing the rounds

Sorry, meant Huddersfield not 'Boro. He was on from the 70th minute and really didn't do a thing IMHO.

Neither did anyone else. Bit weird to single him out isn't it?

[WJ99mobile]

Re: Rumours doing the rounds

That's a bit harsh personally, I don't think that he's the brightest on a football pitch. He's great when he can drive into space with the ball, he's naturally good at that. Ask him to look over his shoulder before he receives the ball, not happening.

He’s not starting XI quality but he may become it. Depends on if a manager is willing to gamble.

[olderblue]

Re: Rumours doing the rounds

With a decent manager he'd be the first down on the team sheet and you would build a team around him

[Pedro de la Rosa]

Re: Rumours doing the rounds

He’s not starting XI quality but he may become it. Depends on if a manager is willing to gamble.

He's miles better than Sawyers and is much more creative than Rinomhota. He should be starting. You've got to get everyone else to cover his deficiencies because he offers something that nobody else in the squad has.

[the other bob wilson]

Re: Rumours doing the rounds

He’s not starting XI quality but he may become it. Depends on if a manager is willing to gamble.

What do you think constitutes a Championship quality player? You won't find many of them without any weaknesses to their game - that would make them Premier League quality (and there are plenty of players in that division with weaknesses). What members of the current City squad do you rate as Championship quality?

[A Quiet Monkfish]

Re: Rumours doing the rounds

Neither did anyone else. Bit weird to single him out isn't it?

I sngled him out because he's become the poster boy for many on here. People are saying we should build the team around him, he's being 'held back' by the manager, we'll lose him to another club, Morison should have gone because he wasn't treating him fairly, etc, etc,.

He's OK, but I'm not alone in those who I go to the games with, that he's just too slow and ponderous, lacking aggression, and currently isn't a shoe-in for selection.

[Hilts]

Re: Rumours doing the rounds

I sngled him out because he's become the poster boy for many on here. People are saying we should build the team around him, he's being 'held back' by the manager, we'll lose him to another club, Morison should have gone because he wasn't treating him fairly, etc, etc,.

He's OK, but I'm not alone in those who I go to the games with, that he's just too slow and ponderous, lacking aggression, and currently isn't a shoe-in for selection.

Lets see what hes like under a new manager.

Your criticism is way OTT.

[sneggyblubird]

Re: Rumours doing the rounds

Lets see what hes like under a new manager.

Your criticism is way OTT.

Essentially he's right though I'd put it a different way as he's like Whitts was, a luxury player we sometimes can't afford.

[insider]

Re: Rumours doing the rounds

Essentially he's right though I'd put it a different way as he's like Whitts was, a luxury player we sometimes can't afford.

What a comment 😂
What I'd do for a "luxury" like Whitts in his prime right now.

[Citizen's Nephew]

Re: Rumours doing the rounds

What a comment ��
What I'd do for a "luxury" like Whitts in his prime right now.

:thumbup: mental isn't it?

[tomcat]

Re: Rumours doing the rounds

What do you think constitutes a Championship quality player? You won't find many of them without any weaknesses to their game - that would make them Premier League quality (and there are plenty of players in that division with weaknesses). What members of the current City squad do you rate as Championship quality?

I watched Joel Colwill play against Newport (albeit briefly) and he seemed very impressive and didn't shirk a tackle either. I've heard a few reports from inside and outside the club that he's got more potential than his older brother.

[J R Hartley]

Re: Rumours doing the rounds

Essentially he's right though I'd put it a different way as he's like Whitts was, a luxury player we sometimes can't afford.

LOL

I despair. I really do.

[olderblue]

Re: Rumours doing the rounds

Essentially he's right though I'd put it a different way as he's like Whitts was, a luxury player we sometimes can't afford.

I think you mean can't afford not to have

[Loramski]

Re: Rumours doing the rounds

Essentially he's right though I'd put it a different way as he's like Whitts was, a luxury player we sometimes can't afford.

Interesting point this, it's a comparison I'd been thinking about myself. I was actually sad enough to go back to April 2017 on here (around page 930) to check it out and the mixed views on Whitts as he came to the end of his time here were very similar to those on Colwill now. I wondered if the same posters were sticking up for both and the previous two posters in this thread both popped up. Older Blue started a thread defending Whitts and JR Hartley was calling Warnock an 'utter c**t' for subbing him against Newcastle.

Out of character but I said something quite interesting, looking back. I pointed out that Whitts had been tried in a number of positions in the previous season or two without really convincing in any but when he got criticised for a poor performance posters would jump in and say it was because he was being played out of position. It seems to be a recurring theme with Colwill now too. There were the same 'lazy/ lethargic/ half-hearted' criticisms aimed at both players by some posters too.

I'm not sure how a lad just out of his teens can be seen in the same way as a man in his thirties coming to the end of his career but, both positively and negatively, there do seem to be some similarities here, to be fair to Sneggy.

[2b2bdoo]

Re: Rumours doing the rounds

Interesting point this, it's a comparison I'd been thinking about myself. I was actually sad enough to go back to April 2017 on here (around page 930) to check it out and the mixed views on Whitts as he came to the end of his time here were very similar to those on Colwill now. I wondered if the same posters were sticking up for both and the previous two posters in this thread both popped up. Older Blue started a thread defending Whitts and JR Hartley was calling Warnock an 'utter c**t' for subbing him against Newcastle.

Out of character but I said something quite interesting, looking back. I pointed out that Whitts had been tried in a number of positions in the previous season or two without really convincing in any but when he got criticised for a poor performance posters would jump in and say it was because he was being played out of position. It seems to be a recurring theme with Colwill now too. There were the same 'lazy/ lethargic/ half-hearted' criticisms aimed at both players by some posters too.

I'm not sure how a lad just out of his teens can be seen in the same way as a man in his thirties coming to the end of his career but, both positively and negatively, there do seem to be some similarities here, to be fair to Sneggy.

Issue is that you need to build The entire team and formation around Colwill if you want him to flourish. Is he yah good? I’m just not sure. If I was manager would I? Probably not.