And what happened then was that people showed their disapproval of what happened in 2008, and to an extent the Gulf War, by voting Labour out. With studies galore showing that the average working person has got poorer since 2010, the richest have got richer, food bank use has exploded, the NHS slipped into crisis and life expectancy went down in the years before Covid, why do you consistently choose to defend the party who have been in power during that time?