
Originally Posted by
JamesWales
The general argument against it is that it costs a lot to administer means testing. Also, the whole system becomes flakier if it relies on people putting money in but then not being able to benefit from it.
Some means testing is right, but some should also be universal. Otherwise, why not ask to see people's bank accounts before they go on the operating table?
The wealthy should pay more in tax, but they have a right to benefit from that collective funding in some cases too.