George Carlin religion

[Baloo]

Re: George Carlin religion

Humanism assumes people are instrinsically good and will choose positive paths for their lives. A mistake.
Also, if humanism doesn't concern itself with a creator why bother setting it against religion, there's there's no competition.

Humanism assumes you can choose to live a good and meaningful life without having to insert the supernatural, out of fear, conceit, or for a longer life, an afterlife or some other reward.

I don’t like the term atheism for that very reason. I referred to Humanism.

[Lither_1927]

Re: George Carlin religion

Thanks for the question about my mental health and for moving the debate to what my lay-preacher friend refers to as the 'pick and mix' fraternity. He is a fundamentalist and and once one concedes that part of a religion is allegory it's a very rocky path. He has left several congregations because they draw the line at allegory in different places and modern-day Archbishops and Popes pick and mix in different places similarly. If part of a religion is conceded as allegory, who is to say what isn't allegory and myth?
However, it's clear that you aren't someone who can debate things in a civilised manner and that you engage in unneccesary ad hominem remarks (such as referring to my mental state) so I won't bother engaging with you. May your God bless you.

What's wrong with pick n mix? As we become more knowledgeable we can decide which is allegorical and which isn't. This doesn't detract from religion.
Autism is a neurological condition and not a question of good/bad mental health. I think i'm being civilised with you but I do think you are on the autistic spectrum which explains certain things. That's not a criticism even though you have taken it as one. I believe that i am on the autistic spectrum and can see certain familiar traits in others.

[Lither_1927]

Re: George Carlin religion

Humanism assumes you can choose to live a good and meaningful life without having to insert the supernatural, out of fear, conceit, or for a longer life, an afterlife or some other reward.

I don’t like the term atheism for that very reason. I referred to Humanism.

But the super natural is there, whether we like it or not. However our existence is explained, the truth will be absolutely mind blowing and defy current understanding. If humanism doesn't touch on this then it doesn't offer a full alternative.
What does humanism say about inherently bad people?

[SLUDGE FACTORY]

Re: George Carlin religion

[QUOTE=Lither_1927;5317246]A recent study finds that people who regularly attend religious services live approximately four years longer than average. Researchers built the study from previous data suggesting that social interaction, volunteer work, and healthy habits can lead to a longer life

A recent survey ......showed that if a load of Christians prayed en masse for someone in hospital it made absolutely no difference at all

People all over the world take part in socialising , healthy habits etc without the need to go to a church

You daft sod

[bigjoe]

Re: George Carlin religion

So who created god?

Yes, but that's the go. God, by any name, is.

[SLUDGE FACTORY]

Re: George Carlin religion

So you believe that God created the earth for humankind but you're not happy about sharing the bit you happened to be born in with people of a different colour to you? What do you think God's take on that attitude would be then?

I was wondering about that 🤔

[Lither_1927]

Re: George Carlin religion

[QUOTE=SLUDGE FACTORY;5317283]

A recent study finds that people who regularly attend religious services live approximately four years longer than average. Researchers built the study from previous data suggesting that social interaction, volunteer work, and healthy habits can lead to a longer life

A recent survey ......showed that if a load of Christians prayed en masse for someone in hospital it made absolutely no difference at all

People all over the world take part in socialising , healthy habits etc without the need to go to a church

You daft sod

You ****ed up the quote mechanism, i hate that.

I think it's important that the actual subject of prayer must also pray.

Anyway link me to your source of information SLUDGE

[SLUDGE FACTORY]

Re: George Carlin religion

[QUOTE=Lither_1927;5317286]

You ****ed up the quote mechanism, i hate that.

I think it's important that the actual subject of prayer must also pray.

Anyway link me to your source of information SLUDGE

Didn't Hitler believe in God ?

The sources of information you have given are American .....they are all fecking religious idiots so you can forget that , you may as well send a survey around a church

Nobel prize winners .....bright people ?

Do you think they are all in church every Sunday?

[Citizen's Nephew]

Re: George Carlin religion

But the super natural is there, whether we like it or not. However our existence is explained, the truth will be absolutely mind blowing and defy current understanding. If humanism doesn't touch on this then it doesn't offer a full alternative.
What does humanism say about inherently bad people?

That could also be said about Quantum Physics and could, mathematically, just be a series of meaningless, random, quantum events. That doesn't mean we don't feel, laugh, cry, hurt etc. but there may be no meaning whatsoever. I often wonder if the dinosaurs contemplated the same things in their much lengthier (sorry for the grammar) time on earth. I think humans are a tad precious. We're extremely likely to become extinct. I don't think any conscious entity is going to prevent that.

[jon1959]

Re: George Carlin religion

But the super natural is there, whether we like it or not. However our existence is explained, the truth will be absolutely mind blowing and defy current understanding. If humanism doesn't touch on this then it doesn't offer a full alternative.
What does humanism say about inherently bad people?

No it's not, whether you like it or not.

Humanism doesn't have to compete with organised (and man-made) religions. Why should it?

It doesn't have to compete with faith (to acknowledge Truthpaste's distinctions, and hatred of religion) or go toe-to-toe with the certainties of cult members.

Human beings can give their own meaning to their lives, create their own values and purposes, and face death without terror. We no longer live in the fear and ignorance of past centuries. We should have grown up!

[Baloo]

Re: George Carlin religion

But the super natural is there, whether we like it or not. However our existence is explained, the truth will be absolutely mind blowing and defy current understanding. If humanism doesn't touch on this then it doesn't offer a full alternative.
What does humanism say about inherently bad people?

I think Humanists would simply believe our existence is mind blowing and defies our current understanding. However there’s no need to insert comforting but implausible answers because of that.

I think Humanists would also believe people have the capacity to be both good and bad. But a better life is built on positive attributes such as learning, reason, compassion, integrity, kindness etc.

[delmbox]

Re: George Carlin religion

I was wondering about that ��

I should warn you, he does not take kindly to the question

[WJ99mobile]

Re: George Carlin religion

What I have learnt from this thread is that there’s a particular person with multiple accounts.

[PontBlue]

Re: George Carlin religion

Oh **** off you sniping midwit. You offer literally nothing. I'd hate to be you.

That's not very Christian of you.

[UNDERHILL1927]

Re: George Carlin religion

I should warn you, he does not take kindly to the question

Ignores it completely in fact, typical religious person response.